MovieChat Forums > Platoon (1987) Discussion > Talk about the Vietnam vets you've met

Talk about the Vietnam vets you've met


In 1980 my best friends stepdad had been a sniper in Vietnam for 3 tours. Real quiet guy, I didn't know what PTSD was back then. One day out of the blue he offered his step son a little taste of what life in the Nam was like. I don't remember much, he said one of his friends was stuck behind an ant hill during a firefight, every time he moved he'd get shot at and they all were laughing at him. Then he asked his stepson how to carry a Fulton at night. My friend put on a red filter and held it up. He said "nah" grabbed the flashlight and stretched his arm to the far right.

reply

I have a neighbor of 20 years who flew choppers late in Vietnam. So late, that his group continued flying combat missions with South Korean troops after US ground forces started pulling out.

He’s a great guy and we try to have breakfast together once a week. Over the years I’ve heard many amazing stories.

reply

My father in law was there in 1968, he was awarded a silver star, two bronze stars, a Purple Heart and an air service badge. He doesn’t care to share combat stories, maybe it’s too difficult or it was all such a fog that he barely knew what was going on at the time.

Vets are like that, they don’t talk a lot about our guys that got hurt or people they had to hurt. But as a history nerd I love talking to vets. I never ask personal stuff like who they killed but I will ask ‘how was the food, is a combat chopper ride as scary as it looks, how did you camp and sleep at night…’

I like those details, vets are often happy to share those small, interesting historical details.

My father in law has an online site to help vets with PTSD and connect our heroes to the help they need. He’s a great guy.

reply

i do not know any nam vets. i am on different continent and no americans where i am

but i like to watch videos of brave nam vets talking about experience. you can find them on american veteran center on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HSBJLD76ak

reply

My father-in-law was a combat engineer who served in Vietnam in 1965-66. He never spoke much about the war at all, and I only knew him for about 4 years before he passed away. My wife never asked him much about his experiences as she has little interest in military matters. He was a very quiet, thoughtful and intelligent man, and I only ever saw him angry once when he was having a problem with his neighbors over their pitbulls. Then he got REALLY angry.

He did say that the only really authentic movie about Vietnam was "We Were Soldiers." All the others, such as Apocalypse Now, Full Metal Jacket and Platoon he called Leftist fantasies with Hollywood degenerates projecting their own dysfunctional personalities and attitudes on American soldiers.

My neighbor also went to Vietnam. We never really hit it off so he never tells me any stories. I have a feeling he would be the kind of guy who would talk a lot about his war experiences in detail.

reply

Leftist fantasies??? You mean they actually depicted humanity in order to relate to the AUDIENCE!

Not jingoistic gun-totin' extremism.

Typical right wing, unstable homicidal Yank crap.

reply

Although I love Apocalypse Now and Platoon I have read a Vet that says that all the events that happen in Platoon simply could not happen during a one year tour.

He didn't really hate the movie as he realized what the director was trying to convey, an enormous amount of events that happened in the war, encapsulated into a 2 hour movie.

reply

I guess you would know better than him. After all, you are some European Leftist in his 20s or 30s who never went to war, and he was just a simple combat soldier with a 12th grade education.

But in all seriousness, since you are too dense to understand, he meant that the standard Hollywood depiction of American soldiers in Vietnam as unstable, mutinous, drug abusing murderous lunatics was very, very far from the truth as he saw and lived it.

reply

In the 90's I worked with an Australian Vietnam Vet, he was telling me about how he and some of his mates went down to enlist because they believed they could beat the draft that way and not be sent to Vietnam. They were sent anyway. He couldn't talk about it too long as he started to freeze up.

reply

One of my first cousins served in Vietnam. I remember he was at our house for a visit when this movie came out...he thought it was pretty realistic in a lot of ways.

Several years ago, I spoke to a Vietnam vet at a local military museum. He had some interesting stories that I wish I could remember. I do remember that he talked about how industrial and creative the Vietcong were...the way he talked about them, it was a tone of admiration, which I thought was really interesting. I really enjoyed listening to him.

reply

GolfnGuitars---that is actually a pretty common thing to hear that the vets did have some admiration for the way the VC and NVA fought. They were very good and resourceful soldiers.

I probably could add some to this thread. I have been thinking about some of the things I recall hearing the past few days. Many of my friends growing up had fathers who had fought in Vietnam. Just a few off the top of my head:

-My one buddy told me that his father had shot a VC through the throat as he was trying to crawl under a fence at their base.

-One guy that worked with my father had been incountry in the spring of 1975 on a carrier in the bay as Saigon fell and they had artillery and rocket fire from both sides going right over top of them as they shot at one another. He also said that private citizen South Vietnamese had tried landing aircraft on their deck and were promptly pushed overboard with the people still in them. i was shocked to hear that.

-Another guy I knew was onboard a ship at Da Nang and he would tell in the day how they would take supplies to the docks on shore to unload. Each night the VC/NVA would blow the docks up and the next morning the US Navy would rebuild them. It sounded like a an oddly organized affair where few people ever really got hurt. Rebuild them in the day and get your work done and then at night they would blow them up. Next day, same thing over. He also talked about how the sailors aboard his ship put in 18 hour days and then you would be so tired that you would just fall down anywhere on the steel floor and fall right to sleep.

One guy who worked at a nightclub I used to go to was there but he just told me he didn't want to talk about any of it when I asked him. I respected his choice. I think most of them did not really care to talk very much about it.

My dad was friends with a guy whose brother had been killed at Ia Drang. The school were I was a student teacher at also had an alum that was killed there.

reply

I very much enjoyed reading your accounts. As the years pass and Vietnam gets more in the "rear-view mirror," so to speak, I think it becomes even sadder in some ways. There is a Facebook group dedicated to the soldiers who lost their lives in Vietnam and it's heartbreaking to read their accounts. Thinking that they would be in their 70s and 80s today had they survived.

That account about the docks being blown up and rebuilt sounds so familiar to me, like I've heard that before from others also. Also, I think sleep deprivation had to be almost universal over there. If I remember correctly, the Vietcong liked to attack at night and when the weather was at its worst (FYI, my late dad fought in Korea and he said the same thing about the North Koreans). I think Oliver Stone did a pretty good job of showing that in "Platoon."

Yes...regarding the Vietnam vet I spoke to at the military museum, I was so impressed with his tone of admiration toward the Vietcong. I remember he talked about how the Vietcong could take simple items like string, tin cans, empty beer bottles, etc., and use them to make deadly bombs. I wish I could remember some more of his stories...I am planning to take my boys there again this coming Summer, so hopefully I will get some more.

reply

Yes, the VC could use everyday items that our soldiers junked in their war effort. We get the one line in Platoon to clean everything up, don't leave anything for the dinks. That was pretty accurate. Good soldiers would leave nothing in the jungle for them to find and use. Either take it with you or bury it where it could not be found.

I was shocked to see in my local paper that a soldier who fought in Vietnam in the latter 1960s was now 90 years old. It is hard to believe how they have aged. When I was in high school most of the vets were in their 30s or early 40s at worst. They were young and virile men. Time has marched on. It is now 50 years since the last combat troops left Nam.

Your father may have also faced the Red Chinese army. They were formidable as they had such numbers to throw at you. One guy who lived in my area was in Korea when China came in and forced a massive American retreat. Guys running and trying to jump into jeeps or trucks trying to get out of Dodge. I asked him once about that and he laughed about it. The old show MASH touched on many areas of that war.

A couple more stories from Nam I recall is the one guy in his first day had his sarge yell at him to check his boots. The guy didn't think it important but the sarge grabbed them and shook them. Out came a poison bamboo viper which the sarge promptly shot with his pistol. Check the boots! Another one was this one guy who said he always loaded his gun with red tracers and it would frighten the enemy away, especially at night. They did not seem to like that.

Yup, the NVA/VC ruled the night and Americans the day. Big advantage the cover of dark provided them against the high tech US.

reply

My uncle did a one year tour as a Huey pilot in Vietnam. When he came home he gave his mother his Medal w/citation and as far as I know NEVER talked about his experience in Vietnam again. He was able to at least work as a civilian for many years, I think he flew Army VIP's around the U.S.

Very outgoing/gregarious I wish I would have got to know him but I rarely ever saw him.

reply

The escalation of the war in Vietnam by Johnson and Nixon was as much of a war crime as Nazi Germany.
The Vietnamese were fighting for their independence at the same time the people of Viet Nam were fighting for their rights against a tyrannical corrupt dictator leader. We bombed the hell out of that country with massive firepower - more than was used in the entire WWII. Then we brought the war in to Laos and Cambodia.

The people of these countries fought and died bravely and courageously for their fellow Vietnamese and their freedom while the US was doing what we have done over and over all around the world. This area of the world has some of the nicest most civilized gentle people, and Vietnam has the best food in the world in my opinion. The US only has relationships with countries that bow down and submit completely to what Washington asks them to do. If they refuse they used to get assassinated, blown up, plane crash, but now they get assassinated in the media or invaded.

JFK was almost surely assassinated by the military/CIA, and it is well detailed in the book "JFK and the Unspeakable" by James W. Douglass. He goes over memos and reports and interviews in minute detail about what JFK was doing and working towards in Vietnam.

The thing is, I believe there is a valid reason the US wants to consolidate the economies of the world - but they never let Americans know what the score is or ask for their approval. That makes our country a benevolent military dictatorship, and is getting less and less benevolent as they realize they can manipulate the masses of people with BS podcasts, fake media, false flag operations and just plain lies. That is what is going on in Ukraine right now.

Americans do not know how good we have it, and now friendly the world used to be to us, until we started support dictators and mafia-like corruption all over the globe.

reply