Theories??


So what is everyones theories on who killed Kate?
I get a weird feeling from the dad, but don't know why.
And I feel the motive has something to do with the pregnancy and someone not happy about it. But sure it goes deeper than that.
What does everyone else think?

reply

I know it's obvious but right now my eyes are on the best friend. Idk his name on the show but he's played by Eric Winter! I also get a weird vibe from the brother and his wife. Everyone is just very suspicious right now lol

reply

I agree with this. His character name is Neil. I think she was pregnant with his child, not her husbands. However, I think the husband found out and actually killed her.
I think it would be quite different from last season if the main suspect actually turned out to be the murderer.

reply

How would have known, we are not even sure there was an affair

reply

That's why it's called a theory.

reply

I think affair is just the first in many red herring we will see. The motive more than likely will be something revealed very late in the series.

reply

That's my reason in thinking it might actually turn out to be the husband who did it.

reply

The detective did it.

reply

I think either the dad or the white sister in law did it. Got vibes from them

reply

I definitely got vibes from the sister in law. Just the fact she's been with the brother for longer and they made her sign the pre nup. But Kate wasn't going to have to sign one. Also Kate being pregnant, if she already knew I'm sure she would have been jealous.

reply

As a couple, there is something not right about them. Maybe they had a threesome with Kate or were blackmailing her to get stuff out of Ealy's character.

reply

They are all suspects, in my book.

The dad, the best friend, the husband, the wife's unborn fetus. All of them.

reply

the dad or the sister Amanda Warner

reply

i want to guess that the dad got his son's wife pregnant and then murdered her. But honestly with the way this show goes it doesn't seem likely. I agree more with the best friend being the killer.

reply

In the beginning when the husband looked at the dad after saying that she was pregnant, I thought that maybe the dad was having an affair with her.But who knows, that theory may be too obvious.

reply

Last year's killer was a shock to me altho I KNEW it couldn't be the dad.

This time will be the same way. There will b e many red herrings and I agree it won't be because she was pg. That is a side issue. Some financial misdeeds?

reply

I think they're making it look like Neil and making it look like he was the father of her baby. I think it's too obvious for Neil to do. Personally I think it was Amanda. Maybe she was having an affair with Amanda's husband and found out who knows!

reply

At this point it is hard to tell. Everyone looks suspicious. Other possibilities are that the mother is actually around somewhere and murdered her daughter-in-law. Or...someone connected to the person he accidentally killed in his past is the one who did it.

Just like last season...this season started out brilliantly.

reply

1. Daddy did it. Terry O'Quinn's always the bad guy/psychopath.
They were in a secret affair when she was his secretary. Her first child is his. He was the only one who was clueless about her relationship with his son. When he found out, he wasn't havin' it.

2. Attorney/sister/best friend: I don't have a motive yet but she's overbearing.

3. Absent mother: Knew about the affair with her husband. Wouldn't allow the skank to be with her son.

4. Drunk baby brother or his simpleton wife

5. But if it plays out like the original series, the secret unknown child did it. Angry that she kept her/him hidden and is celebrating a new pregnancy. lol In this scenario, John's still the father.

BUT what I'm anxious to be revealed is, since Eric ran down the stairs, he knew she'd fallen. How? Where was he? What did he see? What transpired? And how much time lapsed before he found out?

reply

AnnaLynne McCord's character or the sister maybe?

reply

I'm pretty sure it's not the husband or he wouldn't have acted the way he did during the scene's when he was home alone. There's still some characters yet to be seen...mother, fist child. You know it's gonna be some twisted reveal so whatever obvious theories get rid of them...

reply

It could be kate lover

reply