Despite the fact that I love science fiction, more and more I'm avoiding the genre in film, because almost every science fiction movie seems insistent on relentlessly insulting the intelligence of all of their scientifically literate audience. Once in awhile it would be nice to be able to just sit down to watch a sci-fi movie and NOT immediately spot fifty stupid goofs that have me going, "Oh come ON! How did nobody catch that?!" I really don't think that's too much to ask.
These productions cost millions of dollars, take years to make, are worked on by thousands of professionals. Yet, time and time again, dumb and obvious mistakes somehow slip past the producers, the directors, the cinematographers, the actors, the writers, the test audiences, and so on. These goofs range from minor details to plot-breaking absurdities.
Quick example: in Gravity, a movie which purported to pride itself on its realism, they describe the debris cloud as orbiting at fifty thousand miles per hour. Sounds pretty scary... if you happen to know zero about astronomy. Fifty thousand miles an hour just so happens to be twice Earth's escape velocity... which means, far from whipping around the planet and striking them again ninety minutes later, the cloud would simply go flying off into space, never to return. (just one small problem out of many problems with the plot of that movie)
Now sure, I recognize that most people don't know what Earth's escape velocity is, and many probably don't even know what the term means, and therefore obviously would not spot that particular problem. But bad writing is still bad writing even if most people don't spot it, and there's no excuse for professional writers penning a script for a multimillion dollar blockbuster that's supposed to be realistic to not take twenty seconds to google the scientific figures they're throwing into their film to make sure that they're in the right ballpark. If filmwriters were making a historical film about Chuck Yeager and wrote the speed of sound as 2000 mph, or were making baseball movie and talked about how pro players usually pitch at around 180 mph, people would throw rocks at the screen.
reply
share