MovieChat Forums > Red Dead Redemption (2010) Discussion > Red Dead Film: Your ideal Marston?

Red Dead Film: Your ideal Marston?


Who is your ideal choice for Martson if a film version was made?

Here are mine (not in any order):

Brad Pitt
Jim Caviezel
Hugh Jackman

reply

Lucas Black...





Just kidding! I think Gerard Butler, Russell Crowe, Josh Holloway or Adam Baldwin (Jayne Cobb style). I feel like Marston needs to be played by someone who looks a little dirty, not some clean cut, pretty boy moron

Time for some thrilling heroics...

reply

Karl Urban.

The guy and Marston look identical.

--------------------------------------
Deftones makes the world a better place

reply

I concur

Not thought about him but you are absolutely right.

Time for some thrilling heroics...

reply

[deleted]

Jeffrey Dean Morgan.

reply

George Clooney.

reply

I definitely agree with Karl Urban or Josh Holloway. That pic of Urban from Comanche Moon has me sold. Here is a recent pic of Josh as a cowboy on Community:

http://www.criticalend.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/joshoncommunity. jpg

I also kind of think Max Martini could pull off Marston, mainly for his tough guy look and voice, but wouldn't be as good as the first two.
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0242882/

reply

It's funny, I was going to post the uncanniness of Karl Urban to the character, but it's seems I have been beaten to it. It's almost like the character was modeled after Urban's likeness.







My 2 cents

reply

[deleted]

Josh Brolin 100%. He immediately came to mind when I first saw John in-game.

Let a little insanity into your life.

reply

Hugh Jackman looks like him a bit so I would say him

reply

clint eastwood in his prime

reply

Josh Brolin would obviously be the first choice.

Praise the Lord and pass the ammunition.

reply