MovieChat Forums > Attack the Block (2011) Discussion > The reason many people hate the main cha...

The reason many people hate the main characters...


...is not because they are racist or can't appreciate anti-heroes. There have been a lot of posts attacking people for not liking the main characters and I thought I'd add my two pence in defence of those critics.

I think the problem is that Joe Cornish has captured a subset of British society so accurately and the language, costume, setting and acting were spot-on.

The appeal of the anti-hero, such as bank robbers, hitmen, lone cowboys, is that they are at a remove from everyday life - none of us will likely ever be involved in a hold up, will ever be targeted by hitmen, or will ever be in the Wild West circa 1880. Furthermore, anti-heroes are normally never indiscriminate: bank robbers target a corrupt and morally bankrupt economic system that privileges the rich over the poor; the 'heroic' hitmen only tend to go after those who deserve it and don't attack the innocent; the gunslinger protects ordinary people and only takes on the violent. In each case, the anti-hero has a 'code' that they follow, and a cause that we can root for because it is far removed from everyday reality. And there's a vicarious thrill to seeing people do those things that we'd like to do but don't have the guts (Falling Down is a classic example).

The problem with Attack the Block's characters is that they are so real and so much a part of everyday life for those living in Britain and especially London. I think the further away you are from the reality, the better you can like the characters as anti-heroes, so Americans in particular, I have noticed, do like them. Unfortunately, when you are living in a place where gangs of feral youths make you fear for your safety when out after dark, when people are daily stabbed and shot on their doorsteps, when in the London riots last year the youth of our nation went on a vile and destructive crime spree that left a bitter taste in everybody's mouths, making those same people the main characters and asking the ordinary British audience member to identify with and like them is an incredibly difficult ask.

To further complicate matters, their opening action is to mug a hard working female nurse. Instead of taking on bully-boy police officers, a rival gang, frankly anything that could gain our sympathy, they threaten and rob an innocent, decent, vulnerable member of society that couldn't have been better calculated to make us hate them.

Admittedly, the film does settle down into a rather familiar story and character arc where the character does something bad and then seeks redemption through heroic action, and here the film gets it absolutely right too. John Boyega is also a star in the making, and if anyone has seen him in My Murder, in which he plays a real life murder victim in a similarly violent youth gang culture, I'm sure they can agree he's an exceptional British talent and one to watch for the future.

In short, I was rooting for the 'heroes' by the end, but was similarly repulsed by their behaviour at the start. I can completely empathise with people who cannot bring themselves to like them, regardless of their redemptive behaviour later in the movie. Labelling these critics 'racist' or 'unable to appreciate anti-heroes' is just wrong. While in some people, race is probably a factor, I think people don't like them because they so accurately portray the bogeyman of contemporary British society. That is its strength, but at the same time, also its weakness.

reply

throwing the racist card huh even though if they were white i would have still disliked them. not less or more.
John Boyega character was the only decent character and that's because he was the main character. the rest of the group we're just a bunch of annoying chavs.

reply

In short, I was rooting for the 'heroes' by the end, but was similarly repulsed by their behaviour at the start. I can completely empathise with people who cannot bring themselves to like them, regardless of their redemptive behaviour later in the movie. Labelling these critics 'racist' or 'unable to appreciate anti-heroes' is just wrong. While in some people, race is probably a factor, I think people don't like them because they so accurately portray the bogeyman of contemporary British society. That is its strength, but at the same time, also its weakness.


I would agree with you but Why do people love Joe Pesci? That's why people are saying that race is a big part of why people don't like these kids.

It's ok to like more than one actor. :))

reply

Man I don't even want to hear from people whining about these main characters when people liked Satan, vampires, and other demons as main characters. Get out of here with that crying.

You hated them because most were black. Grow up and admit it. End of.

reply

Excellent, concise analysis! Thank you.

reply

The teenagers were all unlikeable. I watched half of the movie and couldn't take it anymore. I was hoping the aliens would eat them all. Normally I'll watch a bad movie to the end if I've made it to the 45 minute mark, but I had no desire to see what happened to those snot-nosed punks!

reply

It's good to read such cogent and well reasoned post. You make a very interesting and compelling case regarding the main protagonists being rather too real for some people.

"You've got lovely eyes Dee-Dee, never noticed them before, are they real?"

reply

Americans in particular, I have noticed, do like them. Unfortunately, when you are living in a place where gangs of feral youths make you fear for your safety when out after dark, when people are daily stabbed and shot on their doorsteps, when in the London riots last year the youth of our nation went on a vile and destructive crime spree that left a bitter taste in everybody's mouths, making those same people the main characters and asking the ordinary British audience member to identify with and like them is an incredibly difficult ask.


You think Americans are unfamiliar with that sort of hoodlum? Americans, hailing from a land where Hi-Hatz would have been the least heavily armed one there, where the gang members could realistically be sporting fully-automatic machine pistols in certain inner-city areas?


You might want to rethink your thesis there, mate.

In any event, I'm an American and I never grew to like them. Dislike them less, maybe, because the movie did attempt to show why Moses turned out the way he did (though it was barely explored) by showing his living situation and the sorts of authority figures he had in his life. But they were still a gang of (conveniently multicultural, to avoid charges of racism, I assume) criminals who attack and rob innocent passers-by without so much as a twinge of conscience. The only one who even came close to showing the slightest human decency was Jerome -- which meant, narratively-speaking, he had to die -- and even Moses' willingness to give Sam back her ring at the end rings hollow when he's sending her out into danger that he only thinks she might survive. Brave man, he was.

reply