MovieChat Forums > All Good Things (2010) Discussion > did they darken the shower scene because...

did they darken the shower scene because Kirsten was shy?


They shouldn't have hired her if she was going to be reluctant to show herself naked. Plenty of other actresses would have done it, without the darkened scene.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5GZIDnMzZQ Why does Canada need a queen?

reply

What does it matter? Did no nudity make any difference to the film? She was surprisingly excellent in the movie and I wouldn't want another actress to do the role purely for the fact they'll get naked

You might lose with me, but you will never win without me!

reply

It must matter somewhat, since you replied.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5GZIDnMzZQ Why does Canada need a queen?

reply

That doesn't validate anything. Check your premises.

reply

I highly doubt that it had anything to do with her "feelings". If the director darkened it, it probably had more to do with MPAA ratings. Kirsten Dunst doesn't care about nudity. Where do you even get the idea that she is SHY!? Thats hilarious!

reply

----------------------------------------
Kirsten Dunst doesn't care about nudity.
----------------------------------------
A few million wish it was true but it isn't.

reply

Don't know what version you seen, but I didn't notice any darkening in what I just watched. There is definite nudity.
Although, even if there wasn't, I don't really see how it would be a problem?


Elle

"If they give you lined paper, write the other way"

reply




http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5GZIDnMzZQ Why does Canada need a queen?

reply

[deleted]

I thought that she was trying to hide the fact that she has no breasts, but then why go nude in the first place? I think that it must have been the mood, many scenes between RG & KD are very dark.

Seriously why would a "big" actress do nude scenes when they have no body? OR worse gross bodies(Maria Bello in A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE?

reply

I enjoy her boobs in the dark or out
of the dark!
There's nothing wrong with her boobs!!

reply

My TV turns itself off occasionally. It is very annoying. For that scene I would have appreciated if it turned off.

reply

[deleted]

No I am not gay... so you aren't getting a date here. When I saw that shower scene though... I wished I was blind.

reply

You'll have to forgive her for not having comically huge breasts, but she certainly, and very clearly, does have prominent breasts. It was an simple brief scene between husband and wife, not something meant to titillate you - if that's what they were going for, THEN they'd have hired an actress just for her huge breasts. Kirsten is well-endowed as she is though. If you want to see novelty boobs, go watch porn. The scene didn't bother me seeming too dark (lighting-wise) or anything, but it was absolutely unnecessary and pointless, so didn't affect the film at all. OP is a pathetic perv. Typical of males drawn to this site.


I met Cinderella once... she's actually kind of a bitch.

reply

Jerry Ripple are you seriously saying that Kirsten "has no body?" Kirsten is one of the biggest actresses in Hollywood and she is extremely beautiful. I do not know what version of the film you saw but the shower scene was not dark and she has perfectly fine breasts.

You obviously have no clue about how nudity is used in film. The purpose for the nude scene in this film was not to arouse the audience. It was to show a woman who was still in love with her distant husband and was trying to find ways to help and bring him back to the person she married. Anyone agree?

"I thought that bullet sounded diffrent."

reply

Kirsten is one of the biggest actresses in Hollywood


Now that's just plain false. She is and has never been one of the biggest actresses in Hollywood. Aside from Spider-Man 2 and Eternal Sunshine she hasn't been in a good movie in the last 10 years until this. And aside from the Spider-Man films she hasn't been in any blockbusters, so no, a big Hollywood actress she is not.

I think she's going nude for the same reason a lot of actresses in her position (ie Neve Campbell) have gone nude. They're past their popularity peek and are probably not getting tons of offers like they used to, so now they must choose between taking crap roles in low budget movies or decent/good roles in indie/low budget movies that require nudity.

There also might be a desire to be "taken as a serious actress", and serious actresses don't have nudity clauses (I'm looking at YOU Natalie Portman!).

Don't try to cash in love, that check will always bounce.

reply

I doubt she was shy. I have seen Melancholia and she is naked a couple of times in that.

reply

Crime noir.

reply

[deleted]

You only watched a few minutes? It's quite stupid for you to judge when you didn't even see the whole movie. She did some great acting in the later scenes.

reply

She was really great in this. You've no clue what you're going on about. You saw what you wanted to see. Nothing about this character was reminiscent of MJ. Her pain and anger over having to get an abortion... her reaction to her first ever hit of cocaine... her excitement over their new apartment... her reaction to finding out the truth about his mother's death... her confronting her husband after he murdered his dog... she was fantastic.


I met Cinderella once... she's actually kind of a bitch.

reply

thats what i was thinking im pretty sure she's been naked before

"Lifes a bitch then you die"

Ben Foster is my Dream husband
Ryan Gosling is my Dream Lover

reply

"they shouldn't have hired her" ?
She has always been a great and natural actress and doesn't need to have an explicit forced topless scene to prove that point and to satisfy idiots like you who always expect to see some boobies. Go watch some porn you loser.





Paul Avery: Someone should write a *beep* book, that's for sure.

reply

Good job, you're a moron.

reply

my god how old is the OP? 12?

reply

[deleted]

She's not shy about doing nude scenes. I don't actually know what you mean. When I saw it you could see perfectly well. It wasn't brightly lit but how many showers are?


"I'll book you. I'll book you on something. I'll find something in the book to book you on."

reply

Well, if you live in a poor country with no lighting I guess it would be dark.

reply

You're a filthy, vile, perverted prick.

reply

[deleted]

To respond to the original question, there is no light in my shower because water and electricity don't go well together.

reply

To respond to the original question, there is no light in my shower because water and electricity don't go well together.


That's absolutely ridiculous.

reply