SO underrated...

I sure as hell feel this way, too. It's almost like "The Rescuers" in terms of underrated-ness, even though, pathetically, this film is much more recent than that. Have yet to see "Frozen" and "Tangled" may not have been terrible, but it CERTAINLY was no where near on par with this masterpiece by far.

while i wouldn't call it a masterpiece, i really enjoyed the film. good supporting characters, i loved the music, a great villain (i think the voodoo element was great), some good side characters and although tiana was a frog for most of it, her character still came through

--------------------------------

To Spamalot or not to Spamalot?

[deleted]

I think it depends on where you live and your surroundings. I just went and saw Frozen today and I really enjoyed but TPAF is still my favorite. I

Just watched Frozen and The Princess and the Frog back to back, and cannot agree more! I was interested in Frozen because i like Disney 'feel-good' musicals, and the trailer made it look very fun, and i was interested in The Princess and the Frog because, well, African American protagonist (I'm white, and non-US, I really wondered if Tiana was going to be a white girl painted black, or a real black character).
Not only the characters in The Princess and the Frog felt more real and evoked more interest and sympathy, the film gave the old Disney animation feel with its music, setting and pace.
Olaf was cute, and obviously very well meaning, but Ray was a much more loveable character with his deep backstory with Evangeline (for a firefly).
I know Anna's naivety was intentional to contrast with Elsa's, but Tiana was a perfect balance between a daydreaming girl and a hardworking woman.
Frozen takes place in some 'fjords' but does anyone care, really? Do people of the fjords look like they have a certain culture of their own? To me, they were only filler, even the trolls who had a musical number all of their own. The Princess and the Frog had backdrop that was vibrant with music, colors, people, animals and food even, you would immediately know where they are even if noone mentioned it, and showing, not telling is very important to me in the art of filmmaking.
I think I can go on for a solid two pages, but you get my drift. I loved The Princess and The Frog and cannot fathom how it scores only a 7.2 where Frozen gets a 8.1 (as of this post). 7.2 is still a lot better than a lot of movies, but independently, i think it deserves more.

I feel like a crapload of heart and work was put into this movie where Frozen, Tangled and Brave are just a bunch of sloppy, thrown together cliches and CGI overload. Entertaining with diverting bubbly animation and catchy songs, but not very imaginative or deep. Fast-paced, wide-eyed wonderment to amuse everyone, especially kids, but still not the best story. Too sugary and perfectly catered to younger viewers and mainstream sounding songs and looks to the characters. The detail and micromanaging there seems to have been with The Princess and the Frog seems so much more. It's a work of art.

It is not only hand drawn and beautifully done, it really developed its story and characters with great balance of heart and humor, and paid close attention and to the jazz-era New Orleans it was capturing which was unique. The songs were great, the villain wonderfully sinister and the humor was original and funny. Tiana and Naveen are very human characters, not cliche or bland, the lightning bug and crocodile are funny and some of the more significant animal sidekicks of any Disney film. Not just there to look cute and provide cheap laughs but they had a place in the story and helped keep it going.

It doesn't feel like any of the classic Disney movies, it feels like its own unique creation and it's all the better for that. Though the hardcore Disney fan crowd would probably not see that as a positive thing.

I have to agree that this is rather underrated. I just rewatched it for the 2nd time since I saw it in theaters and was rather impressed. Unfortunately I fell asleep for a bit (worked all day, can't help it, I get tired). Anyway, I thought both Tiana and Naveen were original Disney characters. I loved that we had a heroine who wasn't fantasizing all day about a boy, but had dreams of her own and making her own business. Of course other Disney heroines have their own dreams, but it was nice to see a blue-collar, hard working girl. We actually saw her waitressing multiple jobs and saving money! I also like how Naveen is basically a playboy at first, arrogant and spoiled, but changes during the film. It's also great that we see the prince trying to make Tiana's dream come true and helping her start her business. The two seem like a great pairing, and have more going on than just an initial attraction.

The villain was also great. He is really creepy and I loved all the voodoo stuff. He kind of reminded me of Rasputin from Anastasia, but it works. I enjoy the Rasputin character as well (historical inaccuracies aside lol). Also the music is very good overall. I know there aren't really any standout or standalone songs, but the songs fit the film perfectly. And the side characters are great! Ray and Louis are very likable, and Mama Odie is very entertaining. When Ray dies it is so sad, but then so sweet when he joins Evangeline in the sky. It was nice getting another genuinely sad moment in a Disney film.

I think TPATF definitely holds up against Tangled and Frozen. I enjoy Tangled, but I've realized some fans really overrate it. It also doesn't have any real standout/standalone songs, and I don't even think the songs fit that film as well. I do enjoy Flynn and Rapunzel though, but I think Tiana is a better heroine. Also I love Mandy Moore's voice, but I actually think Tiana's singing voice is fantastic for a Disney heroine. For some reason I am not sure I think Moore's fits as well (although it may also just be the style they were going with for the music in that film). I just think TPATF has more substance.

Frozen I do admit I really liked. However, it is getting massively overrated. Personally the only standout song to me is Let it Go (which is phenomenal). I consider most of the other songs in the film complete fluff. I get the Broadway vibe, but I really just think they lack substance and are silly (though I do laugh at Olaf's song a lot). Also the trolls are a huge detractor from the film. They definitely bring the film down. Elsa is a really great Disney character though, so the film gets a lot of props for her. Anna is more a standard Disney character, and Kristoph doesn't stand out compared to other Disney men (Flynn probably stands out more to me even though I rank Tangled below Frozen). Anyway, I do have many issues with Frozen but at the end of the day I still love it. I just can admit that it is far from perfect. My point with the critique of Tangled/Frozen though, is that TPATF is just as good as them. It's a shame it is kind of ignored.

Heck I even watched Pocahontas again recently and it really went down for me. It definitely is lacking. I rank Hercules above it (definitely not the greatest, but has heart and is more enjoyable). But Pocahontas always seems to get a ton of love. I'll admit it has some good songs, but the film overall lacks for me (although I love the Savages scene).

[deleted]