MovieChat Forums > Grey Gardens (2009) Discussion > Heartbreaking scenes...

Heartbreaking scenes...


Which were your favorites?

"What difference does it make when one's heart is breaking?" - Carole Lombard [My Man Godfrey]

reply

i wrote this on another post... but .. the scene when "little" edie was going crazy running,screaming,crying while cutting,tearing her hair out... wow...once again=drew HAS to get every possible award she can get

reply

- The reconciliation scene towards the end...she KEPT the wedding jewels!

-Little Edie's childlike resignation to returning home, and the look of shock on her face when she sees the disrepair in the house after being coaxed inside by her mother.

-The slow but subtle return of Little Edie's alopecia.

-Mrs. Beale's flat announcement to Edie that her father had died and that "the funeral was on Tuesday" before leaving the room.

-When GG was at its lowest point during the raid and you get to see how much that beautiful house had fallen into shambles. The tree branch that had grown right through into Mrs. Beale's bedroom and the broken windows with winter rain coming in gave me chills.

-The Edies standing by helplessly during the raid.

Forget about guns and forget ammunition, 'cause I'm killin' 'em all on my own lil' mission.

reply

When Edie stroked Jackie's hair. That alone put me in tears.

If you don't like abortion, don't have one!

reply

[deleted]

So many heartbreaking scenes.

Near the end when Little Edie ran out of the house, I don't know why but that made me sob.

And like many of you are saying, the raid was the depressing.

"...You came to my birthday party just to tell me I should grow up..."

reply

I loved the scene near the end of the movie where Little Edie returns home after running out, and Big Edie encourages her to go to the premiere for the movie. The look on her face is so full of joy. That moment is happy, sad, and touching at the same time in that she is finally fufilling some of her dreams.

reply

There was a scene where Big Edie was talking about how singing was her favorite thing in her whole life and the only time she was happy was when she was singing and went on and on while Little Edie sat prim and properly and silently precious on the edge of the bed looking at her folded hands and then back to her mother and you know she was thinking "what about me mother? wasn't the happiest times having me?' I believed these two women never communicated and took each other for granted. That was very, very sad considering that that old grey house and each other were the only things either one of them ever had.

reply

For me, the saddest scene was during the raid when they were taking the kitties away and going through their things. The way that the Edies were yelling and crying was so heartbreaking. This film was absolutely perfect.

reply

That was the scene for me too. Rarely have the cameras only focused on the chaos of the house. It was always on the women, with the chaos in the background. Always there, like an extra.
But during the raid, it was all about the house and the cats. You're kind of jolted out of this fantasy... The fantasy the Edie's live, choosing not to see the mess and crumbling mansion. But when it's front & centre, it's hard to ignore and it's a very powerful scene!


We've met before, haven't we?

reply

[deleted]

There were so many things that gave me a pang! If I had to pick two though...

I was heartbroken for Big Edie when Gould left her. (The state of the piano later was enough to make me want to cry for her.)

Also, reading the quote of Little Edie saying that her mother gave her a priceless life---I don't know why exactly, but it totally choked me up.

reply

For me it was heartbreaking when Big Edie was telling the Maysles what a perfect marriage she'd had to Mr Beale. It was such a clear lie, yet she smiled and said it as if she really believed it.

reply

The very end, as Edie walks back on stage after everyone had gone and sits down, her quote appears overhead:

"My mother gave me a completely priceless life."

reply

[deleted]

I'm surprised no one has said it yet...the moment when Little Eddie hears herself saying (for the third time) "all I ever needed was this man."

There is a moment that is pure genius on Drew's part - it's so subtle. You can see her suddenly recognize the totality of what she just said. And, then she resigns herself to walk up the stairs...back to her mother.

I mean wow.

I haven't seen the doc yet so I don't know if this came directly from Little Eddie and Drew captured it so beautifully or if it's Drew's creation entirely, but it was stunning. It completely broke my heart because it was so small - the moment I mean. But, so powerful.

I can't wait to see the documentary.



http://www.speakmediablog.com/

http://ca.youtube.com/user/SpeakMediaBlog

reply

You should definitely see the original documentary. It is SO INCREDIBLE how HBO literally recreated the original documentary. I still can't get over it. It is eerie how much Jessica Lange and Drew Barrymore took on the roles as Big Edie and Little Edie. Truly amazing work.

I saw the original documentary years ago and it was the most wonderful, incredible, yet disturbing thing I had ever seen. I literally could not stop watching it - even though at times, I wanted to. It just draws you into it. It is most definitely worth a look.

reply

"I haven't seen the doc yet so I don't know if this came directly from Little Eddie"

It did.

...Grace beats Karma

reply

There are so many, but one of my favorites is when they first take you back in time and pan across the scenery where you first see Grey Gardens at is original - and most beautiful. What an amazing home. The scenery is just gorgeous.

reply

[deleted]

Indeed! That funeral scene was heartbreaking. Nice one!


http://www.speakmediablog.com/

http://ca.youtube.com/user/SpeakMediaBlog

reply

[deleted]

For me, it was the little nuances that were the most heartbreaking.

The utter ruin of the piano. Clearly, a central and core piece of the Edies' identity, especially Big Edie. The film doesn't shove the piano and music down your throat, it's part of the fabric of it all. So, when they show just a very brief shot of that piano's twisted and warped keys -- completely beyond repair -- it's significant. Their lives, like that piano, are twisted, in ruin, and well past the point of no return. That one solitary shot of the hautningly beautiful instrument made me weep.

Every single scene the filmmakers were in. The Maysels. Their knowing looks, their sympathetic eyes. There was nothing about these men that was superficial or sensational. They knew these women were not quite on this Earth, and the admiring pity they showed for them was poignant.

That branch that had grown into the bedroom.

The entire scene with Jackie O. Wow. There just are no words. When Little Edie strokes her hair, which then sets off her crazy tirade, and Jackie's reaction without a hint of resentment is priceless. It's all very raw and very manic and very sad. The hair I could have had, the hair that should have been mine, the life that should have been mine, the life I've wasted in this coffin of a house. Beautifully written work, there. Beutifully acted.

That first scene with little Jackie and Edie at the beach. I knew it was a scene that would mean something later, and for some reason I held on to it. It's not specifically heartbreaking, but I had a feeling about it, and it struck me. And later, when Jackie says, "you know what I remember most about Grey Gardens? Summers here." It just got me.

Drew's look of shock when she sees the disrepair and manic hoardiness the house has fallen into when she returns from NY, and then later, her resigned understanding when she walks in with teh cat food and melted ice scream.

That final shot with the quote that her mother gave her such a great life. And you want to just die. The mental illness was so genetically pervasive, yet also so learned, and also so done unto her. Oh gosh. Tragic.

reply

WELL SAID. All these things.
the piano for sure.

The way Jackie responded to what she was experiancing, every second I was like, how is she going to respond to this?

And the Maysels.

I hope everyone noticed the parallels in Both Edie's movements when they were not in sets together (going back and forth, say between New York and Grey Gardens.) very subtle but amazing directing.

reply

[deleted]