MovieChat Forums > This Is England (2007) Discussion > How do Americans generally perceive Brit...

How do Americans generally perceive Britain?


With the heavy influx of immigrants from the four corners of the earth, the rising crime rate and the fact that London as a city is barely 50% white British any more I thought that the American myth of Britain being a homogenous, immigrant free, prim and proper, rural country of little country villages with friendly vicars and church spires had been firmly put to rest.

Admittedly, I haven't spoken to many Americans about this topic, but of the 70% I have, most of them have held the view of Britain that is a very homogenous society of low crime rates, low immigration, high reverence in the royal family, have the lowest crime rates in Europe, are patriotic and in some cases are very religious.

As a British person, this image of Britain being a conservative, low-crime, homogenous country just doesn't sit with me. We're one of the most multicultural countries in Europe - even in the smallest towns in the UK people of races other than white are visibly represented and in the bigger cities they often number more than whites - and I'm not even getting onto the fact there's quite possibly getting on for a million Eastern Europeans living in the UK.

As for low crime rates, statisics often suggest we have some of the highest crime rates in Europe, which is quite plausible, there's some nasty bits of work in the UK. Patriotism and reverence for the royal family is long gone, quite often there have been cases of being putting a flag out on their house only for the local council to request it's removal. Flags create a massive stur in the UK, there is the constant fear they will offtend foreigers and upset the multi-cultural balance. As for the royal family, they are of no consequence to the UK anymore, you've got to remember even countries like Sweden and Holland have royal families.

As for religion, if you find a less religious country, let me know.

reply

[deleted]

I can only speak for myself ,but I think when you say Britain I tend to see each country differently. England I see as the hub ,very multicultural ,particularly London & Liverpool ,but still maintaining a great 'English' tradition. Wales as a country trying to recapture it's heritage ,it seems Welsh people feel the English robbed them of their culture. Scotland seems to maintain it's identity ,and heritage while still heavily contributing to British culture as a whole. N. Ireland ,I don't know what to make of it ,it seems like it's still a country in flux (are we Irish ,are we British). As far as British multiculturalism is concerned ,yes it's one of the most diverse in Europe (a result of Empire),but still not nearly as diverse as the U.S.(a result of slavery ,and our relative youth).

reply

It is true that the image we get of the UK is from television and movies. We only get a handful of British shows here in the states and most of them are older (from the 60's to the 90's). I grew up watching Are You Being Served, Keeping Up Appearances, Fawlty Towers, Last of the Summer Wine...even Flying Circus. So my point is that growing up my view of what Britain is like has come from these shows. Now my love of British film and TV has stayed with me as I've grown older so I still try to watch a bit of the new stuff now and then and I have noticed it is a lot like you say.

I would love to visit someday. My ex-girlfriend's family was from Manchester and I got along with them great, and I honestly liked the food they made too. They made these thin British-style pancakes with lemon-juice and sugar in them and I would love to be able to find out how to make them. I've never had anything else like it here in the U.S

reply

British Pancakes? Try the "Swedish Pancake mix" in your local supermarket. Lol
--
If my enemy's enemy is my friend, is my friend's friend my enemy?

reply

BTW ,I suspect the "flag waiving" comment was not meant literally ,but more a metaphor for jingoistic nationalism. Some of us are still struggling with the myth of American exeptionalism which was a by-product of cold war propaganda. The problem with propaganda is otherwise rational thinking people tend to believe it even after it has outlived its usefulness.

reply

I wish Britain was like how the Americans perceive it to be, sadly its become a 3rd world toilet.

reply

You should go visit a 3rd world country sometime. you'll see why your comment is bigoted, redundant and retarded

I'd rather be hated for what I am than loved for what I'm not

reply

My father being in the U.S. Air Force, I lived my pre-teenage years in Suffolk county during the '60s where my view of life in Britain fit exactly with what has been, much as you described, this American myth. No doubt the past 40 years has seen quite a dramatic change for which this American view of Britain, for most Americans, has not quite kept pace. This Is England offers a fine mid-point view, between 1965 and 2005, of the changing and progressively multi-cultural life in both countries.

reply

The only thing i'd say about this is that London is about as typical of the rest of England as New York is. London isn't England by any stretch of the imagination. I live in the midlands and every time I go to London it feels like a different country. Any Americans wanting to experience England shouldn't stay in London in my opinion.

reply

many of the "english" people i have met seemed to have a superiority complex. i mean they can be cleaning toilets for a living but they would still act like they were the prince of whales.

its funny how America has always been a country of immigrants yet as soon as the immigrants started getting darker...people began to panic. i hate double standards.

all major wars...most serial killers...hate groups...consist of white (anglo) people. yet we are afraid of darker individuals. its ridiculous...

where ever there is poverty...there will most likely be crime...this a well established fact.

reply

I think that as long as we continue to keep score with race then racism is alive and well. The OP lists racial statistics about Britain as if they need to prove something. Britain is in Europe, I am no more offended about Europeans in Britain as I would be about too many Chinese people in Shanghai. This is absurd to me.

As far as perception of Britain, I will say that overall I think of Britain as being safer to walk the streets at night. Maybe a slightly more educated society overall. I'm sure Britain has got some mean streets but if you take the worst neighborhoods each nation has to offer, I don't think there is any comparison at least that is the way I perceive it. London is comparable to New York as far as being a thriving mega-city but New York has a reputation for having rude people that are in a hurry all of the time but I found London to be quite friendly. Certainly more friendly than Paris. My main perception of Britain before I ever visited was that it was probably a nice place to live. Then the usual stereotypes like bland food. And it's overcast a lot but I'm from Texas so I am used to clear sunny skies nearly everyday. I am also used to hearing over-the-top stereotypes.

reply

From what I see on American TV & especially Family Guy in particular, Brits are very posh, polite, well spoken/educated, have big/badly maintained teeth, and are all members of Gentlemen's Clubs where they sit in big leather chairs drinking Brandy & reading the papers.. This is a very outdated perception of us.. What we actually are are is closer to typical American society than we have ever been, we have so many influential cultures here we certainly are not that quaint olde worldy country that harks back to the 1940's anymore

www.cannabisgrowguide.net

reply

I am an Australian who spent three years living in the UK and I agree with you about the perception of the UK being incorrect but I think the same is true of every country. People's views of countries they haven't visited are going to be formed through tv, movies, books and hearsay and I don't think there's much we can do to stop that.

People's ideas of Australian life when I was staying in the UK didn't sit well with me either, but there's nothing much we can do about it. And I am sure that my view of America is highly inaccurate.

I think unless people travel to other countries they are just not going to know what those places are really like. Which is why I travel.
.....
"No time for the old in-out,love-I'm just here to check the metre" A Clockwork Orange

reply

[deleted]