Such a moving film


This film is honestly one of the most touching movies I've ever seen. I've seen it multiple times already and I never fail to cry buckets everytime I watch it. It just strikes a chord in your heart that moves you so deeply. So, so good.

reply

[deleted]

Have to agree with you both, such a lovely film, ending would bring tears to a glass eye i might add.

reply


Not that moving, it's good but not that sad or touching. Interesting film, but not a masterpiece.

reply

"Not that moving, it's good but not that sad or touching. Interesting film, but not a masterpiece. "

Agree 100%

Great cinematography, good acting, nice scenes, but the story itself is not great at all.

A lof of movies are better about the history and more moving. Phenomenon by example, of P.D. I love you.

reply

There's two scenes in particular that make me cry. No matter how hard you try to fight it off.

Bathtub scene: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fgTSa9ViWY

Ed Bloom (senior) is in the bathtub and Sandra Bloom (senior) gets in with him, when he extends his hand out and she moves in to embrace him and starts to cry:

Ed Bloom: "Come now"

Sandra Bloom: "I don't think I'll ever dry out."

The River: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCbdX92hbbg

What can you say?

Gets me every time.

"Toto, I've [got] a feeling we're not in Kansas anymore."

reply

The end/river story just....man it just kills me everytime...

cant help but shed a few tears for that one, definately one burton film i love above others

http://thesilverscreenjunkie.blogspot.com/ - Lets discuss movies without IMDB haters!

reply

One of the only scenes that I remember really making me cry a bit was when Edward comes back from the war after Sandra thinks that he's died. It is a moving film in many ways but that part just got me the most for some reason.

reply

Not that moving, it's good but not that sad or touching. Interesting film, but not a masterpiece.
Who said anything about a masterpiece?

The whopping majority of the folks who watch this film find it to either be "sad" or "touching." For what reason would it need to be a masterpiece to induce tears or emotion?

Frankly, half the films I find "sad" or "touching" aren't ones I'd classify as masterpieces. The two ideas are totally unrelated.


Or did you purposely mean for your two sentences to be totally random and unrelated in regards to one another?





I'm not a control freak, I just like things my way

reply

Hmmm...I've watched it twice now (once a long time ago, and just recently), and it seems like sentimental pap. Neat, so Dad tells outlandish (and frequently boring to watch) stories and his son doesn't like them.

reply

Yeah it got me on the end, with the river story, dang...

"I'd say I'm sorry, but you know it just wouldn't be sincere..."

reply

Yes, the ending when the son still doesnt believe that a lot of the stories were true but some were because the people involved came to the funeral, that was touching. I thought it was a cute story nothing too outlandish but i found it enjoyable. Each to their own. :)

reply

I'm male and 22, have seen all the classic tearjerkers, Grave of the Fireflies etc, and I have felt the lump in my throat at times(About Schmidt's ending does this) - but this is officially the first movie I've cried to. That's impressive considering I had no expactations except some eye-candy in the usual Burton style. I must say I'm grateful someone could show me what it's like, since you read about it all the time. Good work!

If dolphins are so smart, how come they live in igloos

reply

yeah...this is one of the few movies that gets me every time...the scene at the end by the bed when the son finally "gets it"...it reminds me of sitting by my father's bedside as he lay dieing. so, yeah, gets me every time.

reply

I love this movie... One of the few films that gets me every time.

reply

I watched a long time ago but didn't really get it, yesterday I re watch it with my mom and sister and it hits me! Both of them were bawling their eyes out but I've got some sniffles too. Classic.

reply

you bet it is.
for every man who had a great father who, as they say, was able to make even the most mundane stories breathe life, it is a movie that will move you. have seen this a few times and am always in tears from the moment he is in hospital.
miss you dad

reply

I lost my father pretty much the same way earlier this year (and yes he told pretty grand stories of his own hundreds of times till I could memorize them but I never doubted him as we knew it was all real) and this movie literally made me cry trembling, I never recall such an occasion before. It just struck home in every way possible. While my uncle was utterly bored at the same time and couldn't shut up talking about the most mundane stuff until the hospital scenes.

reply

yup... i saw this film right after my dad died and it was just impossible not to cry... great movie and one of Burton's best..maybe because he was using someone else's story?

don't think he's made a great film since.. Tim's early stuff is all amazing.

reply