I guess I could answer my own question by saying "well then there wouldn't be a movie," but I was thinking, why did Alonzo involve Jake in anything? Not just the raid on Roger, but the entire day?
Alonzo has a really pressing problem: he has to raise a million bucks before midnight, or else he's dead. So why make this Jake's "training day"? He seems to have enough clout (his own car, not needing to check in at the station or an office etc.) that he could've just told Jake "Look, something has come up, consider this a day off with pay, meet me tomorrow at 10 AM at the same coffee shop."
Jake was completely not needed — as a knowing accomplice or as a hapless patsy — for anything Alonzo needed to do that day in order to save his own life. Shaking down Blue, ripping off Sandman, paying off the Three Wise Men, raiding Roger, all could've been done without Jake being there.
Not knocking the movie — like I said, without Jake, there'd be no story — just making an observation.
Alonzo planned all the week for that day, I think the plan was to let Jake be killed by Smiley since the beginning and I think he knew a rookie wouldn't get the money, so there he goes 250,000 more for the pocket.
^^This. Alonzo even tells him that he was planning it all week. He had planned from the start on what he was going to do with Jake.
"I am the ultimate badass, you do not wanna `*beep*` wit me!"- Hudson in Aliens. reply share
I think Alonzo was baking the plan and then Jake was assigned as a routine thing - it was just random chance. But once he was assigned, Alonzo figured he could blend him into the plan. If Jake went along with it and took the money, then there were more cops to testify, making it look cleaner.
If Jake didn't go along, he became a disposable piece that Alonzo can pin a lot of stuff on.
If you overthink most stories they fall apart a little, but OK. Let's try this. Say this is how it happened: Alonzo had already chosen Jake as a candidate for his squad, based on his attributes, and his naiveté. He seemed like someone Alonzo could mold over time but was still a solid cop.
Then the incident in Vegas goes down with the Russian.
Hoyt's first day is already scheduled, probably as a genuine kind of interview type of trial. Alonzo takes a look at Hoyt, thinks about Roger's big stash and knows it the only way he can get that much money that quickly. So he takes a gamble and involves Hoyt, figuring the whole thing will go down better with the shooting board, the Three Wise Men, and the public if someone above suspicion does the shooting, a rookie with no blemishes on his record and no prior connections to himself or his team.
He concocts the idea of getting drugs in Hoyt's blood as a way to control him later after the raid on Roger's, since he's brining him along pretty fast. But, after the events of the day and Hoyt's reaction to the shooting of Roger, Alonzo feels that the threat of drugs in his blood won't be enough to keep the honest and righteous Hoyt in line or even quiet, and goes with the backup plan he'd put in place, just in case, and calls Smiley.
The way he looked at it, none of his guys catch any blame, his problem goes away, nobody will miss Roger, and Hoyt is expendable. If it worked out and Hoyt turned out to be as crooked as the rest of them, then he has a new team member who is shackled to him because they're involved in a murder together. If not, then Hoyt vanishes after the shooting, maybe gets found murdered in gangland and it's viewed as some kind of retribution for Roger.
That's the way the plan was supposed to work out. And the one thing that screwed Alonzo's plan up, namely his Plan B, was the one thing that Hoyt did during the day that Alonzo didn't control or put in place: Hoyt jumping out of the car and saving the girl who turned out to be Smiley's cousin. It was the one decent thing he did the whole day and it ended up saving his life.
Jake doesn't have to be there, but it's a nice plus. Stands to reason that Alonzo has enemies in the department and doubtful his guys aren't 100% clean either. Why bring them extra scrutiny? Besides, maybe Jake does pull the trigger or at the least he takes the money. Then he's culpable AND Alonzo owns him for the rest of his career.
Up until the end, where Jake finally gets the upper hand, Alonzo is basically Kayzer Soze (Usual Suspects reference). He had the whole thing planned out before the movie started, and he even picked up on little clues along the way (i.e. the rape victim mentioning the Hill Side Trece, the Chinese Menu on his car at the beginning which he uses as a fake warrant at Sandman's, etc). I suspect that he initially was going to kill Jake afterwards all along, but as he got to see him in action, could tell he was a proficient cop (the magic eye) and was thinking of giving him a pass until he wouldn't go along with killing Roger.
My ballot goes indeed to the raid on Roger. A rookie (thus above suspicion) getting carried away on his first day and pulling the trigger. Self defense. Quite foolproof. I'd say there could have been an even more solid setup of the scene: shooting Roger while Jake's in the kitchen, wherever, then actually making him believe it was self defense and telling him to take it upon himself (that way finally passing the test). But of course, there would not be a movie then :)