I show this movie in my 7th grade science class and have not have a negative reaction from any of my students (I've shown it for the last three years). Some of the students do get a little upset at times, as do I when I see some movies, but not as traumatized as your daughter.
It is a fairly scientifically accurate film, and I show it after I finish my unit on volcanoes. I think the school psychologist is the one who traumatized her more than the movie. In recent years, very few people have died from volcaones because scientists usually know when they are getting ready to erupt and can send out adequate evacuation warnings. The chances of getting killed from a volcanic eruption in 2008 is slim to none.
I have students in my class who come from Ecuador and Columbia and have had first hand experiences with volcanic eruptions...they were fine with the movie. Some of them even had love ones who were injured trying to evacuate. For them, this is a real occurance, and they are glad that I showed them the movie.
In your area, I would refrain from showing your daughter Twister, because that would definately traumatize her. Maybe you should ask her what specifically caused her to be upset...it could be the grandmother dying or other people getting hurt, or the reality that some people have to go through that reality.
I hope this helps.
reply
share