MovieChat Forums > Field of Dreams (1989) Discussion > All my friends agree, he was out of his ...

All my friends agree, he was out of his wife's league!


Kevin Costner was sort of the matthew mcconaughey of his day. Your mid-western style of good looks. He was a "star". His wife in this? Amy Madigan? Forever known as "Buck's girl" as in John Candy's movie "Uncle Buck."

I have no problem with her being five years his senior, as Kevin (who was 33 when shot) could pass as late 30s.

I do have a problem believing that he would have chosen her out of a plethora of sexy chics who's head he would have turned.



reply

In my mind, using Amy Madigan as a somewhat plain, goofy, borderline hippie type character made the idea that she would humor Costner's character's nonsense as he plowed under their crop to build a baseball field - just because he heard a voice in his head telling him to do it - more believable. You'd struggle to believe why a much more attractive woman with more options herself would put up with him; the movie would have to waste a lot of time explaining it to make that believable.

Plus, Costner's character didn't really have much going for him in the way of ambition. So the pairing worked for me even though, admittedly, the sound of Madigan's voice is sometimes tough to endure.

reply

Good point, never thought of it like that.

reply

Here’s a direct quote from the book what touches on the pairing of Ray and Annie:

Now I stand ready to cut into the cornfield, to chisel away a piece of our livelihood to use as dream currency, and Annie says, “Oh Love, if it makes you happy, you should do it.” I carry her words in the back of my mind, stored the way a maiden aunt might wrap a brooch, a remembrance of a long-lost love. I understand how hard that was for her to say and how it got harder as the project advanced. How she must have told her family not to ask me about the baseball field I was building, because they stared at me dumb-eyed, a row of silent, thickset peasants with red faces. Not an imagination among them except to forecast the wrath of God that will fall on the heads of Pagans such as I.


The book doesn't describe Annie's physical appearance much, but without picking nits Amy Madigan even in a little makeup is a pretty good choice in terms of appearance. Chapter and verse mention something about her having short, curly red hair, green eyes and a sprinkling of freckles across her nose.

You're quite right, actually. Baseball isn't really Annie's thing, but she endures it (goes to games and whatnot) because it makes Ray happy and gives both of them a chance at unfettered, carefree "together time."

Now where building the field is concerned I can't help but think that her viewpoint is something along the lines of, "Well, okay maybe it's not the most wonderful idea since sliced bread to come along. But at least he's not out killing anybody, so what harm is there in at least letting him try?"

Ray sucks at farming, but to say he hasn’t much ambition is a tad harsh. What ambition he has is largely devoted to keeping Annie as happy as he can. Dr. Phil of our own day might argue differently, but in the way of ambitions is that truly a bad thing? 





reply

There's a thing as too sexy (tiring). And really attractive people tend to be empty & less attractive on the inside.
I saw FOD in the theater when I was 21, and discovered Amy, and found her sexy (I like natural, petite, red hair, down to earth)

_____________________
Steps to a great life:

Watch Twilight Zone
Listen to Wayne Dyer
Go vegan

reply

Well, first of all, Matthew McConaughey is from TEXAS. Texas is not "Midwestern." Second, I thought that their relationship was perfectly reasonable -- they met in college and fell in love and stayed together. Amy was prettier in the "college" pic, and he also clearly loved her incredible loyalty and belief in him (demonstrated throughout the film), her beliefs in the 1960s ideals they both shared, and her feisty spirit (the PTA scene). People fall in love for many reasons -- not merely looks.

"Hearts and kidneys are tinker toys! I am talking about the central nervous system!"

reply

From a superficial standpoint, she was probably a bit foxy back when they met (yes, you couldn't tell much of a difference in their college photos but still). That being said, I honestly thought the same thing. But they had great chemistry, and in my mind that's enough to buy them as a couple.


... the niña, the pinta, the santa maria

reply

I thought Amy Madigan looked pretty in Places in the Heart, where she played the mistress of her real life husband Ed Harris.

reply

I get the distinct feeling that Ray "settled" a lot in life. He pretty much let the wind steer his ship and he was lucky to find any port at all.

It's almost like Costner's role in Fandango but a dozen years later and without the draft dodging element.

reply

Maybe I'm nuts but I think Madigan is very pretty with a smile that just lights up her face.

reply

she's a cutie. I love her spunky personality and how she always supports her husband.

reply

Keep in mind, they met while at college. They were at Berkeley so she probably wasn't facing very stiff competition. And he admitted to smoking a lot of weed, so that might have affected his judgement. Maybe she had his hook up for the best stuff. Then once she got him in the sack, she wowed him with her amazing skills, and he could never get her out of his head.

reply