MovieChat Forums > Radio Days (1987) Discussion > seth green getting slapped around

seth green getting slapped around


I don't know how this scene is supposed to be considered nowadays -- especially in the U.S. where child abuse/torture/mortality/murder rates are now the highest in the world -- but witnessing an 11-year-old seth green (portraying a young woody allen) getting slapped upside the head and knocked around like a punching bag by his 300 pound father was not only not funny, but extremely distasteful to watch. how many others had a visceral reaction to this scene? I know i did, and it wasn't so much because the scene was overly graphic or violent in nature, but the very idea of a fully grown adult picking on or abusing a child -- let alone their own child in this day and age -- is shameful, immoral, cowardly and disgusting as well as a reprehensible act of unjustifiable violence. Ironically, many people who have no problem justifying such violence toward another human being wouldn't dare as much as raise their voice to their dog.

reply

I laughed and laughed at that scene. The rabbi dissing the kid's upbringing in front of the parents...can you imagine that happening today? That's why it was funny.

reply

I'm watching it now and just noticed that scene. It was shot in 87, and in 77, that was still pretty common to have parents knock their kids around. For the timeframe, my parents said pretty much anyone (neighbors, teachers) could give you a biff for getting out of line - I used to see friends get their asses handed to them on a weekly basis.

The other thing that caught me was how old the parents looked for having a new child. Funny how times change.

reply

Be reminded the movie takes place in the late thirties to early forties. Such things were commonplace way back when.

reply

The Rabbi and his father slapping him around scene was the funniest scene in the film. It's a movie for crying out loud, get a life. Stick to cartoons, you seem ridiculously fragile.

reply