MovieChat Forums > Fitzcarraldo (1982) Discussion > Fitzcarraldo NOT in the Top 250? Absurd...

Fitzcarraldo NOT in the Top 250? Absurd!


Fitzcarraldo is clearly one of the greatest, most artistically ambitious movies ever made. Fitzcarraldo also cut through social and cultural barriers.

I know a ranch-hand, a man from central Mexico who, when asked what his favourite movie was, the man answered (in Spanish): "There's a film,I can't remember the title, about a man who lives in the Amazon and tries to take a huge boat up one side of a mountain and down the other".

I know an Astronomy PhD in Galactic Structure who considers Fitzcarraldo to be "one of the greatest films ever made".

I know a businessman who told me Fitzcarraldo was "one of the most joyous experiences I've had in my life, certainly the best movie".

When queried a bit further, it turned out none of these three knew IMDb existed.

One more: I select and screen movies every Wednesday at a local non -profit cultural center. The second film I screened was Fitzcarraldo, and 45 people showed up, with no publicity whatsoever. Since then, the best crowd I've had, with publicity, has been thirty or less... except for (ahem) Cobra Verde, which I screened a month and a half later, separating them on purpose. We hit 45 people again.

My personal take on it: Fitzcarraldo is a perfect, stand-alone counterpart to another masterpiece, Apocalypse Now. Where Apocalypse showed the dark side of the jungle (civilized man gone wrong meets the jungle), Fitz showed the illuminated side (civilized man in his purest, most idealistic form, meets the jungle). Apocalypse may have had Brando in unpredictable form, but Fitz had Kinski in top form!

However, Fitzcarraldo is a film that many USA filmlovers don't know, since it's not often screened (theatre) or shown (TV). USA filmlovers are by far the biggest voting block in IMDb.

Surely Fitzcarraldo deserves better. So what do you say, people? Let's kick this movie up, let's put Fitzcarraldo into the radar screen where it belongs!

reply

As much as the 250 list is, in it's own way, great.. It would bring in a lot of people starting "overrated!" threads.

Just look at the 2001 message boards.. lots of people coming in and going "greatest movie ever?.. it was sewww boring. blah blah blah you film buffs don't know what's what."etc.

reply

I remember enjoying Aguirre so I watched this. Got to the hour mark, didn't find it too impressive so stopped watching. A few months later I put it on again and was blown away, not only did it completely surpass Aguirre (which would still make my top 100 mind) but it makes my top 10.
Its a movie I can watch repeatedly or just have on as background noise, I find it very calming.

reply

Not only should it be in top 250. It should be in top 10 considering the efforts put to create such an enigmatic piece of cinema.

But of course not everybody will agree.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Indeed it is absurd. As someone else mentioned, there are no Herzog in the top 250. I saw this film last night and it was a great great film experience. I saw Aguirre, the Wrath of God and The Enigma of Kasperh Hauser, both interesting and intriguing. I´ve seen some of the docus by him. But Fitzcarraldo is my favorite piece by far.


Where did you learn to spin, No-Face?

reply

Yes totally agree,where is the top 250?

reply