MovieChat Forums > Slaughterhouse-Five (1972) Discussion > My Reaction On Seeing Slaugterhouse Five

My Reaction On Seeing Slaugterhouse Five


I saw this movie when it came out in 1972. I was saw it alone and the reviewer said that it had science fiction and sex in it. About five minutes after leaving the movie I got very angry about it. I remembered my grandmother who had been
murdered by the Nazis for being Jewish. Kurt Vonnegut Jr. seems to equate to bombing of Dresden to the holocaust. Slaughterhouse Five shows that the worst people in the movie, i.e. those that made Billy Pilgrim miserable were his fellow American Gi's, not the German wardens who behaved quite properly. Only after Dresden has been bombed does it show that the maddened Germans kill his
friend.
Kurt Vonnegut, who is of German descent, tries to minimize the Nazi crimes,
has written that the Germans were bad almost in a light comical way. Of course,
other German cities were bombed as severely as Dresden, only they did not have
the same artistic architecture as Dresden did. Also he has written another book
where Israel has a Nazi criminal, but the criminal is American.
Kurt Vonnegut claims to have been a witness to the bombing of Dresden but I have read another book by Victor Klemperer, I Will Bear Witness, who claims to
have his life saved by the bombing of Dresden. He was a Jew converted to Christianity with a non Jewish wife. These type of people where treated badly
by the Germans but not sent away to the concentration camps. That is, until Feb.
1945 when the Nazi policy changed and they were sent away. There were about 100 of them in Dresden and when Dresden was bombed they were about to be sent away.
After the bombing, Klemperer and his wife fled to another German city and said that all his documents were destroyed in the bombing. So a few Jews actually had their lives saved in the chaos from the allied bombing of Dresden and other German cities.

reply

[deleted]

.................. hold on a second... isn't this entire thread subject to Godwin's law... from the first post onwards?

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

This isn't about Jews.

reply


Heich-1, Ive read this thread Ive read you're view on slaughterhouse five and the responses, and I have to say you seem narcissistic, and not very observant about the movie. Dresden was a terrible act where thousands of innocent people were killed. Dresden was wrong, Hiroshima was wrong, bombing of London was wrong, 9/11 attacks were wrong, two wrongs dont make a right and innocent civilians dying is not right. Also you mention how Lazarro an American GI and POW was the most obnoxious character well yea, and Im sure there are plenty of obnoxious American soldiers. However you seemed to have not noticed Edgar Derby the older American soldier who befriends Billy, he is portrayed extremely positively, he is kind and sticks up for Billy, and Billy seeing him get killed, along with Dresden bombing is what leads to Billy's post traumatic stress. Also for the record I am American born All-American, I am not a 100 percent militarist but I am no pacifist either. My grandfather was an American soldier in World War II and won medals for his service as a Lieutenant Colonel, even he had problems with war, he would not have liked innocent civilians getting killed. My two cents.

reply

It's a movie....So watch it and let it alone. A history lesson is not needed or your life story....IT'S A MOVIE. Maybe you better just stick to really simple movies.

reply