MovieChat Forums > The 300 Spartans Discussion > 300 Spartans, but 7,000 Greeks.

300 Spartans, but 7,000 Greeks.


While there were 300 Spartans at the pass at Thermopylae, there were 7,000 Greeks in total. The film drastically underrepresents Greek numbers in order to make the stand seem more heroic than it was.

I'm not sure if I should submit this as a historical goof. I don't recall if the movie ever said how many Greeks were actually present. But the film is intentionally misleading on this point.

One the third day, when they were outflanked by the enemy, the Spartans dismissed their allies and prepared for a last stand. 700 Thespians insisted on staying with them and died along with the Spartans. Since they made a larger sacrifice, at least in terms of numbers, perhaps this film really should be called "700 Thespians."

The film doesn't ask this, but what's so heroic about dying pointlessly anyway? Sure it took lots of courage, and it's in keeping with the romantic Spartan warrior ethic, but for those of us who have an entirely unromantic and unsentimental view of war, the idea of men queueing up to die when they don't have to and when the battle is already lost strikes me as idiotic, not heroic.

reply

This entire battle has been debunked before, there is no way the Persian army was anywhere near the size suggested, there just wouldn't have been enough food/supplies available to support that size of an army even short term. Likely the odds were less than 10 to 1.

reply

Actually the battle is considered one of the most historically documented of any ancient battle. That there were several million Persians has been called into quesiton, with most historians estimating the Persian hoard at about 300,000 500,000, whcih is still several times the number of combatants in any ancient battle.

reply

According to history the 700 Thespians were nothing as far as the combat skill of the 300 spartans and that is what is part of the main focus. That they were the best warriors of thier and possibly all time.

reply

Let's not ruin a good story by dragging too much of the truth into it.

Gentlemen, you can't fight in here! This is the War Room!

reply

Exactly.

Gentlemen, you can't fight in here! This is the War Room!

reply

I think the point of the film is to show how "few stood against many." It's more of a life lesson really, standing up for what you believe in. Pointless, you say, of this battle? What will you do that will be honourable enough for remembrance and talked about until the end of mankind?

reply

"this film really should be called "700 Thespians.""

Historians discussed this with film directors and the consensus was that the egos of actors are big enough already. 

reply