That is beautifully said. Very nice analysis of the movie.
As for reasons not to like it here is my view:
This film is not entertainment, it doesn't lift spirits, it doesn't have conclusive positive bang! in the end. That alone can cause many people to dislike it. Hollywood movies taught us that life is hard, but if you try hard, life leaves you shiny presents of happiness, family and prosperity.
Fellinni manages to paint bleak and very realistic picture using his unique style. Marcello doesn't know what to do with himself, he is spinning wheels and getting nowhere, the mid-age crisis hits him, and he tries to find what is he doing wrong. Money, family, religion, simple life, they all seem to be elusive and promising from the outside, but when it comes to mundane reality all of those aspects reveal emptiness. He doesn't need to be loved, money is not his highest priority, he doesn't enjoy limelight, he is not believer, and his party life doesn't bring joy anymore. What he wants - is creative expression, he wants to express himself, but realizes he has nothing to say. I know many people, myself included, who go through similar struggles. They bring insecurity, fears, even phobias, and it takes time to accept reality, and become hopeful again. Steiner is unable to accept reality, he succumbs to his phobias, and that frightens Marcello, so he hits partying as a refuge, a way to desensitize from his worries and fears. The last shot of the movie - the face of innocent girl is the most remarkable moment of the film, it actually shows the ultimate recipe for happiness - live the moment, and love people around you.
I guess if you don't go through tough times, or if you don't like to think about philosophical subjects, like meaning of life, happiness, creativity, this movie doesn't offer a lot. It is rich with beautifully crafted highly symbolic scenes, every small detail has meaning, images are stunning, music is perfect, lots of subtleties, challenging acting, any movie connoisseur would enjoy, but if you like bold, straight forward topics, cliché stereotypes and happy conclusive endings there are few reasons to watch it. Which is fine. I would be very surprised if this movie appealed to the crowd as wide as any major Hollywood hit.
reply
share