MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Why don't we hear the banjo in all types...

Why don't we hear the banjo in all types of music?


Perhaps I'm wrong, but I don't recall ever hearing the sound of a banjo on any hip hop or rap record. Come to think of it Heavy Metal groups don't use the ? banjo either. Every rock band has a guitarist, why not a banjoist? Okay I know they are called banjo players, but it sounded good with the -ist. You don't hear the banjo on jazz or blues records. Beethoven didn't write a concerto for banjo. What do people have against this great musical instrument?

reply

One word: Gangstagrass...Check 'em out, they're awesome!

reply

Ya know I was just joshing but wow that is super cool. I will check that out!

reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xR3CNEdoPJc

reply

Thanks for the link. Cool song.

reply

It's a great show, too...Highly recommended!

reply

Rock: -
The Who - Squeeze Box.
Led Zeppelin - Gallows Pole.
Neil Young - Old Man.
The Eagles - Take It Easy.
Buffalo Springfield - Bluebird.
Porcupine Tree - Trains.

reply

Yeah, but those are isolated songs here and there. We need more banjo and more banjo themed groups. Billie Ellish and Taylor Swift need to start playing the banjo in their songs.

reply

There’s always Deliverance.

reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrlqQ1_vZVE

reply

I remembered that wild and crazy guy could play the banjo. He recorded some bluegrass albums, too.

reply

I was just listening to the band Heart yesterday, and there was a banjo in the song, and it sounded great.

reply

You hear some banjo here and there , but it is mainly in bluegrass music. I am just kidding about more banjo, but it has a unique sound that could be used more often.

reply

Its sound isn't associated with rock. Neither are harps, accordians, xylophones nor violas.

reply

Or bagpipes

reply

Yes. I meant to mention bagpipes.

reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWwAv_oKPEs

reply

Bagpipe Rock Band:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBNxbbix1qk

reply

Not bad, but I think they should stick to parades and funerals.

reply

I'm Shipping Up To Boston by Dropkick Murphys

Bagpipes.

https://youtu.be/x-64CaD8GXw

reply

Like the tune. Didn't care for the vocal. Saw an accordion and the elusive banjo, didn't see bagpipes. I see on their Wikipedia page that they do feature a bagpipes player.

reply

I don't think there's any type of musical instrument that's typically heard in all, or even most, types of music, except maybe for drums.

"Every rock band has a guitarist, why not a banjoist?"

The same reason they don't typically have someone playing a ukulele, mandolin, harp, lute, kantele, etc. Each type of music has certain characteristics which identify it as that particular type of music. One of those characteristics is the type of instruments that are typically used. While there are always some oddballs, like Bon Scott playing bagpipes in "It's a Long Way to the Top (If You Wanna Rock 'n' Roll)," if bands started making a habit of throwing in random instruments, their music would start becoming a different type of music.

reply

I don't think that there is anything wrong with that. I know for example that John Mellencamp had his band around the "Scarecrow" album trying different instruments to make a different sound. Unique can be awful but also very good at times. I'm joking about more banjo but why not let bands try to integrate different sounds in their music. Like REM used a toy piano in "Stand" which created a unique sound to that record. Yeah a whole album of that might be awful, but ya never know.

reply

WHEN I THINK BANJO..I THINK TWO THINGS...NED BEATTY RAPE AND ANDY/DWIGHT JAM SESSION IN THE BREAK ROOM.

reply

Two very different things!

reply

BOTH ENTERTAINING SOMEHOW THOUGH.

reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXB3sSArfuA

Some banjo in this hard rock song.

reply