MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > How the fuck can anyone hate Spielberg o...

How the fuck can anyone hate Spielberg or Scorsese?


Seriously? How?

You want me to talk about movies. I'm talking about movies. And I don't get you people who don't rate these absolutely amazing filmmakers.

It's almost akin to a classical music fan saying they hate Beethoven.

reply

Both are excellent movie makers imo
I think some of the criticism comes from a younger crowd wanting to seem hip and edgy, hating on the art that came before them

Jaws, Taxi Driver, E.T., Goodfellas, Saving Private Ryan, Mean Streets...

C'mon, is it even possible to disrespect these guys??

Spielberg and Scorsese are brilliant

reply

I think some of the criticism comes from a younger crowd wanting to seem hip and edgy, hating on the art that came before them
And, going by what I know of some of the posters here, a few older people too who also seem to think it's hip, and possibly edgy, to hate on anything that reeks of popularity.

reply

I need some evidence here Malko...seems you are out on a limb

reply

I've got to be careful here. I don't want to make any (more) enemies.

But there are a few threads on this board, and the Schindler's List board, that make me think we have a few Spielberg and Scorsese haters here. And that's perfectly fine. It's their prerogative. I just don't get it.

reply

Look another friendly and reasonable conversation between the two of us.

And yet, you've now chosen to attack me in quite vile terms.

Do you have a personality disorder I should know about?

reply

Have I been 'vile'
Maybe so, I honestly forget

Quote me Malko...

reply

Yes you
You are a bore
Do you think you created your schtick..? It's as old as the hills

Nobobody likes what you do
Get your shit together or shove off dummy
And you said some stuff about no-one caring if I was gone, or some such shit.

reply

You just come off all bitchy and mean buddy...just relax, drop the rants ,hang out...
We are mostly a cool and fun bunch here

Start a funny thread and have a laugh👍

reply

Maybe I'm not that funny a guy.

reply

I bet you could be though👍
You gotta dig deep for the entertainment and comedy...I go for it often and agree that it's really hard (I miss half the time LOL...)

How's about you get off your political butt and attack this site with silly games, dumb comedy and random stupidy with me from now on?
I'd be pleased to work with a tenacious fellow like you

reply

Thanks for laying off me and reaching out. You're displaying the reasonableness I associated with you, which is why your earlier attacks were so baffling to me.

I'd expect them from some other posters here, mostly, but not exclusively, those on the far-right of the political spectrum, and maybe a few of the more zealous ones on the far-left, but you seem(ed) like one of the nicer posters here, and LauraGrace hadn't given me any shit before, so I was at a loss to understand where the abuse was coming from.

reply

Yeah, politics aside let's just keep it level and honest

I am a difficult person and you don't seem so easy...this should be a hell of an effort but making friends is important

I Will start with a positive statement about you: you stand up for what you believe in

I respect that


reply

Oddly enough, until today I did take you to be one of the easiest and most amiable posters here. Until today, you'd given me zero shit (like I say, that's why it hurt more to be so harshly criticised by you than it might have done to be criticised by certain other posters here).

But you're right, I am not an easy person. I am very uptight. Even when I get that people are telling a joke, I can't always take a joke (most of the time I'm good at detecting sarcasm, and yet it's still my default to take people seriously and at face-value). Still, I forgive easily and I don't hold anything against anyone. If someone apologises or is willing to build bridges, I'm more than willing to let bygones be bygones. I've got no time for harbouring anger towards people, and, as long as they're civil, I'm willing to engage with 'enemies'.

But thanks for your words, 'you stand up for what you believe in'.

reply

I'm not reading that wall of words goshdarnitall!!

Say that in 15 words or less Malko😉

reply

Read it, you will cry. It’s all about building bridges and engaging with enemies and letting bygones be bygones...

reply

yeah, like using the term "fuck" on every thread and board to draw attention to yourself in that hip/edgy way. You sound like a jerk.

reply

I am.

Clearly you're an amazing judge of character.

reply

"I think some of the criticism comes from a younger crowd wanting to seem hip and edgy, hating on the art that came before them"

Little do they know it does NOT make them seem "hip" it makes them seem like a dumb little kid.

reply

they are masters of their art.

reply

I don´t hate Scorsese but to me he is one of the most overrated directors. Goodfellas is probably the most overrated movie of all time right after The Dark Knight.

reply

"Goodfellas is probably the most overrated movie of all time right"

Say it ain't so, Billy! I thought we were "Friends".😞

reply

lol

reply

The Dark Knight is not overrated!

reply

Taste?

reply

Spielberg movies are too sentimental for me.

The opening scene from saving private ryan where the family walks to the grave makes me cringe.

reply

The worst was when they are walking through rubble, and a GI asks, "Who are you?"

"I'm Ryan"

hooray!

I'm not a fan of Spielberg, not his movies, or his latest head-case power move, wanting to eliminate any competition so his movies can be given sympathy awards.

I love Taxi Driver, but 99% of that was Paul Schrader's script (which is online, he describes every detail) and Robert De Niro (who hasn't done shit in over 20 years)

reply

He invented the Hollywood cliches and tropes.

reply

Elizabeth Banks called out Spielberg for never directing a film with a female lead. I guess she thinks another director did The Color Purple.

reply

She probably thinks Oprah directed that one.

reply

[deleted]

you got problems fighting with everyone on here

bad analogy about classical music, who are you to tell OTHERS what they can or cannot like? they SUCK DICK

reply

I'm not telling anyone to like anything?

reply