Robo Picard's synthetic body is a major plot point in S3 though.
In the ST universe the transporter does not kill, but transports the matter (via a matter stream) and reassembles the body afterwards. Technically it's still the same body.
Yes there are episodes in old Trek where characters die and come back, but the robo Picard story was not necessary at all, it did not add anything to Picard's character. It had nothing to do with good story telling, let alone science fiction, but certainly more about disrespecting old Trek and one of its main character.
Remember when a janitor in DSC was cleaning up a room of goo and they called him 'numbnut'? He answered with 'my name is Gene' (as in Gene Roddenberry) only to get "I've already forgotten that" as an answer. Yep, that's Nu-Trek in a nutshell.
The nostalgia factor in S3 was great, the story not so much.
reply
share