MovieChat Forums > His Dark Materials (2019) Discussion > How is everyone finding The Subtle Knife...

How is everyone finding The Subtle Knife AKA HDM S2?


The Subtle Knife was the first book of HDM I immensely enjoyed, probably because of the fact that Lyra visits Will's world (our world) and the sheer coolness of the Knife itself.

As for this adaptation that's showing at the moment, I'm not sure about some stuff about the Magisterium and the Witches, and did Will have grandparents? Is that an invention of the adaptation?

Luckily I read all three books in 2004, and so I have my own headcanon of how events play out in my mind. I still don't like the idea of black Will.

reply

Actually Will is biracial. But why does it matter at all?

reply

It matters because the people who cast him did it because he was biracial. Whether he was a good actor was a minor consideration obviously. So this production has been disadvantaged by having a mediocre actor cast in one of the two leading roles because being woke is more important than being good.


reply

I haven't seen Amir Wilson in anything else. But the character of Will Parry is like this. He's had to take responsibility from an early age. He tends to be stoic - not the sort to break down and pour his heart out in a really dramatic scene, tears streaming down his face. He keeps a lot to himself. In some respects Lyra is the opposite. She also had to shoulder a lot of responsibility for her age, but is more outgoing with less of that stiff upper lip. I liked the scene in the movie theater where she let Will know that just because she seems care free sometimes does not mean she doesn't take things seriously.

I looked Wilson up and his handful of credits are mostly stuff aimed at kids. That would be why I've never seen him before. I guess we'll have to wait and see whether he can play characters completely different from Will Parry. That's the true test of an actor.

It's been a long time since I read the books. Don't remember how Will was described there, Pullman may very well not have explicitly mentioned the color of his skin. To say they cast Amir just to check a diversity box is a hell of an assumption. They had a lot of kids audition for the part. I assume they picked him for better reasons.

Actually he reminded me a bit of Luke Skywalker in the tower, getting his condensed Jedi training from the former Bearer. Alright, here's your lightsaber. Switch it on. Swing it a few times to get the hang of it. Now focus, let the Force guide you - you got the idea! Okay. Gotta go. You'll figure the rest out. 😳

reply