MovieChat Forums > They Look Like People (2016) Discussion > Slightly Offensive (slight plot spoilers...

Slightly Offensive (slight plot spoilers)


I will start off by saying, despite a nice look on a microbudget, I wasn't impressed with it as a movie. I think the internet reviews gave way too much credit to "doing so much with so little," but forget there are movies like Tangerine out there, filmed on phones.

I found the views of women and mental illness a little offensive. Yes, I get the point was to make a horror movie, but this has been done before, with so much tenderness and care for the real disease, that is came off as abusing mental illness as some kind of threat to society. Knowing people who have suffered from paranoia and schizophrenia, the idea that this man could essentially live a normal life and switch one and off, is incorrect. Also, the blame wouldn't be a girlfriend, a friend, or anything else, but a true fear that someone was after them....constantly.

I also didn't like that a woman was the basis for each character's demise and each character's weakness or realizing their weakness. The addition of a female character who is seemingly impervious to emotional attachment and/or pain made me feel like the director was hashing out some resentment and not really making a film about mental illness. This is actually a common theme for college film projects, which, despite the clean look, was exactly what this was.

I will say one thing for the movie....the opening scene made me hope there was more to that moment and if there had been, the movie could have taken a very different, much more original twist, than the obvious ending.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I also didn't like that a woman was the basis for each character's demise and each character's weakness or realizing their weakness.

You are open to the possibility that this isn't what's actually in the movie, but merely what you are reading into it, though, right?


--------------------------
I will miss this hellhole.

reply

I'm open to a lot, but that was actually in the movie. Kind of hard to miss the FACT that Wyatt and Christian's behaviors start because of breakups. It's actually in the very first scene. I'd love to hear how this wasn't in the movie and I'm misreading it. I mean, even Christian's firing is related by Mara. You realize you missed this and it's pretty obvious, right?

reply

You realize you missed this and it's pretty obvious, right?

I didn't miss anything. It just seems like we have radically different definitions of the word "basis". When Mara simply informs Christian of his being let go (even in the most sympathetic way possible), and we clearly see that he was actually fired because of his own behavior (the post-it note), then I have a very hard time seeing how a woman is in any way the basis for Christian's demise in this regard. As for his general situation in life, the movie goes out of its way to overemphasize this character's extreme insecurities and tendencies to overcompensate, and yet you still contrive an external reason for his weaknesses/realization of his weaknesses. The women in this movie simply are not portrayed as the catalysts of the events. The main characters' problems all stem from within.

As for Wyatt, you actually are misrepresenting the beginning of the movie. Wyatt's demise (I'm going with this word because it's the one you chose in your original post) isn't caused by a breakup. HE breaks up his relationship, because he's already so deep into his psychosis that he imagines his girlfriend to be part of the demonic conspiracy. However, she is in no way portrayed as a causal factor. Hell, she's hardly even a character at all. If anything, she serves merely as a signifier for the audience to understand just how close Wyatt's delusion (which by that point we're still made to perceive as a legitimate threat) has crept up to him.

So, yeah, I don't think your original claim about women being the basis for the characters' demise is actually supported by anything in the movie, especially not when you take the ending into account where it's revealed that Wyatt had been wrong in perceiving *any* of the characters, females included, as demons and that his problems are actually all internal, not external.


--------------------------
I will miss this hellhole.

reply