MovieChat Forums > Rogue One (2016) Discussion > Star Destroyer withing atmosphere?

Star Destroyer withing atmosphere?

posted 8 years ago by killerklown420
32 replies | jump to latest

Should that even be possible? Would they be able to keep that much mass hovering within a planet's atmosphere?

[–] bummerinthesummer 8 years ago

They had an entire city defying gravity, floating in the clouds in Empire Strikes Back, a space ship doesn't seem that greater a stretch of the imagination to me.

[–] nubbage 8 years ago

Wow this thread is very long. One and only correct answer:

Star Wars is fantasy not Sci-fi.

[–] ARCtrooper-5555 8 years ago

The fact is there's plenty precedent for it already within the fantasy world of SW. So it's not out of place, even by fantasy SW standards.

"Silly TFA apologists!" = 🙉🙈🙊 

[–] gav3eb 8 years ago

More believable than the Enterprise being underwater in Star Trek into Darkness.