MovieChat Forums > Rogue One (2016) Discussion > So it's common acceptance this is the wo...

So it's common acceptance this is the worst Star Wars movie, right?


I do believe that the general consensus among real fans is this movie ranks lowest.

Revenge of the Sith > Attack of the Clones > Return of the Jedi > The Empire Strikes Back > The Force Awakens > The Phantom Menace > A New Hope >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Rogue One


Are you extremely disappointed with Disney over how this movie turned out? Do you think Disney is going to create more bad Star Wars films? George Lucas must feel so guilty selling Star Wars to a company that doesn't care.

reply

No this is the best one since Return.

reply

LMAO!

You fail as much as the Atlanta Falcons.

reply

Yeah well your analogies fail as much as .... a ... bad...analogy.

Regardless, you liked Attack of the Clones better. I don't need to entertain your opinion.

reply

Keep on failing, champ.

reply

Your list fails as much as the Cleveland Browns!


"The mission... the nightmares... there... finally... over." - ARCtrooper Fives

reply

The fact that you have Sith and Clones as your top means you are a dumb ass.

I told your mom to get rid of you when we found out she was pregnant, now look what happened!

You are such an embarrassment to me.

- Dad

reply

The fact that you are butt hurt that I called this movie out for being the worst proves you are a fake Star Wars fan. Sorry you can't accept that those two are the best Star Wars movies.

Get triggered, noob.

reply

No. this is the BEST Star Wars.

God dang it I'm good

reply

Damn millennials. It's probably people like you that caused these forums to get shut down.

reply

Self awareness levels are dangerously low!

reply

Anyone who rates 'The Farce Awakens' above anything, but especially above ANH has indisputably proven their idiocy! Only a moron would approve that shallow, pandering, contrived, fan-fiction ripoff of ANH over the real thing!

I was about to say that you have the intelligence level of your avatar. But yours is clearly lower.


"The mission... the nightmares... there... finally... over." - ARCtrooper Fives

reply

A New Hope was boring. The Force Awakens took the formula of ANH and improved it. Plus with much improved special effects it's way better than ANH. Sorry you can't handle facts, kid.

reply

A New Hope was boring. The Force Awakens took the formula of ANH and improved it. Plus with much improved special effects it's way better than ANH. Sorry you can't handle facts, kid.

Wrong! TFA did a bad job of copying ANH with new characters that were archetypes from a preteen Disney warrior princess movie, converted the Force into Disney magic, and pretended to give depth and intrigue to the story and characters with JJ Abrams mystery box nonsense. It was a nostalgic trip back through ANH with faster pacing and better special effects. But it was one rehashed ANH moment contrived to next in ways that made no sense at all other than force the story ahead to next point!

(Just 2 examples of many: Kylo kills the only guy who knows where the map is before he even knows about Poe or BB8! R2D2 wakes up because it's time for the rest of the map to show up in the movie. The Resistance have no idea where the rest of it is or what to do now that they have the one missing piece that the First Order needs. Nobody thinks to check Luke's droid in all those years? "Hey! Let's just take R2D2 with us everywhere even though he's been unresponsive all these years!" and the Resistance is too stupid to suspect that he might have the rest of the map! Apparently R2D2 is loaded and moved every place Leia goes over the past 10 years because she uses him for squats and leg presses!... Or maybe she uses him for a jewelry box!) But there's so many more moments like that in TFA.

ANH was far better written and laid out in storylines and character development and plot! But you wouldn't know that because you're too busy getting excited by the loud sounds and bright colors!




"The mission... the nightmares... there... finally... over." - ARCtrooper Fives

reply

#RIPIMDbMessageBoards

You said it yourself pal, we're the guardians of the galaxy!

reply

It's a shame. These damn kids are to blame.

reply

general consensus among real fans




If you feel like Picard screaming how many lights there are, it's time to walk away from the thread.

reply

worse than FA? what are you smoking?

reply

Nope. That is not the common consensus. Only you arrogantly trying to pass off your personal opinion as common consensus.


"The mission... the nightmares... there... finally... over." - ARCtrooper Fives

reply

The Empire Strikes Back
8.8

A New Hope
8.7

Return of the Jedi
8.4

The Force Awakens
8.1

Rogue One
8.1

Revenge of the Sith
7.6

Attack of the Clones
6.7

The Phantom Menace
6.5

reply

Yeah, trolls make multiple accounts and rate the movies wrong. And?

reply

Yep. This is the general consensus for all the live-action films. And it's mine too, for the most part.

reply

Revenge of the Sith > Attack of the Clones > Return of the Jedi > The Empire Strikes Back > The Force Awakens > The Phantom Menace > A New Hope
Whatever you say, boss.

reply

dude, I can only hope you are trolling, R1 worse than TFA...? Goddamn pre-millennials, nothing good ever came from your generation. You will burn in SW hell for this.

🐾Dictated but not read 🐾

reply

Here they are ranked from best to worst:

1. A New Hope
2. Return of the Jedi
3. Empire Strikes Back
4. Space Balls

(big gap)

5. The Force Awakens/Rogue One/The Phantom Menace/Attack of the Clones/Revenge of the Sith

Deciding ranking on the last group is just splitting hairs, they are all pretty terrible.

reply

Only the PT movies are below 8 in user ratings, and movies 8 and above are pretty good. User ratings are the best way to find out what fans in general thought of the movies.

reply

Your beliefes are falls.

___
https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/petition-to-keep-the-imdb-messageboards-going

reply

Your beliefes are falls.


English class called buddy. They're wondering if something went wrong in the bathroom since you left to pee 14 years ago.

reply