Poor Joanie - Some Insights
I’ve mentioned before that I’m a therapist, so I will give a therapist’s POV on the rather perplexing behavior of Alison in the final 2 episodes in Season 2.
It is well known that some parents of children who have died end up overindulging and even spoiling the next child. That child, the replacement child, feels pressure to live up to the ghost child and invariably falls short, creating all sorts of dysfunction.
Some parents handle it well. They work through the indescribable grief. They treat the new child like a completely separate person. Everything ends up ok.
Then we have people like Alison. If the writers of the show really want to redeem her in Season 3, after her abysmal behavior in the final 2 episodes of Season 2, they will show her as a mother who was terrified to bond with her child because of what happened to the one who came before her. This is a common, but not often talked about, phenomenon. We don’t like to think about parents not bonding with their kids. It’s scary. There is actually great physical and emotional risk to the child when a parent, especially the mother, does not bond emotionally. But it happens more than we would like to think. And if the writers take this angle, it would at least help to explain Alison’s strange behavior and make her more sympathetic, just as Noah was shown to be more sympathetic as Season 2 wrapped up.
We talk on these boards like these characters are real people. It’s because they feel real. They’re imperfect. The crazy plot twists have been pretty farfetched, however the essence is real, and it’s what keeps us hooked – these are people we can relate to. Or not. We like to think, “I’d never be like Noah, or Helen, or Alison, or Cole.” But secretly, we think “I’ve done that,” or “I *could* do that,” and it keeps us watching.
What has been so disturbing to me is how Alison could choose a restaurant over her kid AND allow a guy who she KNOWS is NOT the father (thanks Maury) raise her in her absence. When Alison is 80 and Joanie won’t visit her, the fact that The Lobster Roll was awesome and terrific is not going to be much consolation for the dawning revelation that she really, really screwed up her priorities.
In life, we may not get it right with adult love, but loving a child is easy. It’s so, so easy, because children have an infinite capacity for love. Adults tend to see love divided up into pieces of a pie, and when it’s all used up, it’s gone. Children tend to view love as something they can give 100% to everyone they know. And to see Alison reject that in favor of the freaking LOBSTER ROLL is just difficult and painful. But in real life, just like with the affairs, the yelling, the betrayals, the secrets – that happens too. And still we watch.