MovieChat Forums > Nymphomaniac: Vol. II (2014) Discussion > So with all the BS she shares....

So with all the BS she shares....


He decides to rape her (essentially) with his creepy uncirced penis???? An empathic person wouldn't take advantage...ya think????

reply

Or he isn't socially educated enough to know when and how to go after sex with a woman who has proven to be very promiscuous and open sexually. He was pretty naive about everything she was talking about. Yet, all of a sudden, he was excited in a way that he'd never felt before. If you know anything about male sexuality, we don't think much when most of our blood in a fully erectile penis. So, he was doing everything he was doing on instinct.

reply

And after he saved her life she shot him.

And let's not forget she tried to shoot another guy in cold blood earlier but she couldn't operate the gun correctly.

reply

Another guy? It was Jerome.

Let the trolls of IMDb howl in despair for I have returned!!!

reply

The problem with this statement is that during the scene in question he was obviously not erect in any way. He clearly had no idea what to do in the situation and was clueless about how to properly initiate sex but even a kindergartner understands that it is wrong to touch someone without their permission.

reply

He felt they’d built enough of a bond to be able to touch her, and god knows he’d heard enough stories from her about animalistic fucking that he didn’t think she’d mind him being number 10,001.

reply

Was he trying to rape her or was he trying to initiate sex?

reply

Was he trying to rape her or was he trying to initiate sex?



In order to qualify as sex he needs her consent.

He attempted coitus while she was sleep (unable to consent) instead of initiating with her before she went to sleep or after she woke up... then he tried to justify his behavior (and her giving in) by using her past sexual history against her.

So, yeah, this would probably fall into the category of coerced sex ,i.e., rape.

reply

Nah, he wasn’t trying to rape her, just thought it was appropriate to stick it in given all her stories and the fact that she called him her ‘first true friend’.

reply

You're obviously American at that. You do realize the US is the only country that routinely circumcises their poor boys without religious cause. I say a circumcised penis is "weird & deformed" as it's surgical mutalation without medical cause! Mutilation! Why harm & cause great pain & distress to a baby because women are too uneducated to learn the truth. Taking away 30-40% of their sexual pleasure does cause it to be along the lines of female mutilation in Africa! Having NO medical causation & finding the uncleanliness issues ALL DEBUNK, aa in total nonsense is why most insurance companies don't cover it anymore! So the US rate of circumcision is now less than half and decreasing rapidly. Btw, you saw MANY uncircumcised men in the movie, you just didn't notice because once erect the foreskin moves back.

As for rape. Didn't see ANY forced sexual relations. Just because you the viewer found the man unattractive doesn't mean it was rape.

Not to be completely rude but exactly how immature/young are you making this nonsensical comment?

reply

Good for you

Now ask me how I really feel, I'm just here for the comments.

reply

When a man tries to have sex with an unconscious woman, that's rape - she cannot consent. When she wakes up and says no and he tries to coerce her based on her extensive sexual history, that's rape. What's hard to grasp about this? It only didn't happen because he was shot.

You're absolutely right about the circumcision, however.

reply

Only womens and cuck's think this guy deserved to die, he shouldn't expect she would open her legs like nothing but she shouldn't kill him either, the guy wasen't a threat to her

reply