MovieChat Forums > Alien: Covenant (2017) Discussion > Why Have Such Hicks in Charge of Humanit...

Why Have Such Hicks in Charge of Humanity's Future?


These are a bunch of brainless country bumpkins to have in charge of the future of humanity, don't you think? Wouldn't you have military-level people in charge, with some integrity, judgment and responsibility?

reply

https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Golgafrincham

Think of ship 'B' and why it was sent first.

reply

They certainly made some moves that weren't real smart.

reply

If they were even half competent then the movie wouldn't happen.
This is what I hate the most about Prometheus and Covenant: Characters making stupid decisions just so the plot moves on. Otherwise, there's no plot and no story, unfortunately.

reply

Yes, Damon Knight called stories like these idiot plots. If the characters had half a brain, the story wouldn't be possible.

reply

Show me the link to damon knight? He died on April 15, 2002 at age 79

Science fiction writer and critic Damon Knight, in his 1956 collection In Search of Wonder, attributes the first use of the term to author James Blish.[1] Knight went on to coin the term second-order idiot plot, "in which not merely the principals, but everybody in the whole society has to be a grade-A idiot, or the story couldn't happen."[1]

reply

"If they were even half competent then the movie wouldn't happen." That applies to most films.

reply

Ridley Scott will do anything for a quick buck these days, even outright ignore amazing lore expansion done by James Cameron is Aliens...

reply

Add to that: You would NEVER have BOTH the Captain AND the First Officer go down to the planet together. Period.

reply

I enjoyed it all Agriculture made the US the power it is today One of my favorites of 2017 better than IT

reply