MovieChat Forums > Sinister (2012) Discussion > Unintentionally Funny

Unintentionally Funny


This movie starts scary and promising.

5 minutes later it turns out to be unintentionally funny.
-attic scene - tropical animals running around there, main character falling through the attic floor, hilarious scene. it's too cold to be outside yet there are tropical animals around and no-one cares to exterminate them.
-screaming kid - screams like hyena - that was over-exaggerated and wtf moment.
- TV and media - film roles of murders just waiting to be found out - starting as family movie cuts to murder scenes in you tube manner of few seconds plainly edited as if murderer is high quality film technician,
main character watching his own tv interview as if it's for the first time, boogie-man moving on screen when you don't watch: something like mona lisa
- boogie man jumping in and out of everything, more funny than scary.
- therapeutic talk with a cop who don't believe in ghosts - why not let that cop walk around the attic?
- you have all gadgets at disposal, but however you just don't use them to film the phenomena around the house.
- hysteric wife, who just happens to realize, after approx 10 years, she married a writer.

Conclusion:
Bad and lame movie.

Supernatural elements are for kids, not scary at all. they are turn off for horror movies. I always looked it like this - if supernatural elements were real - why they don't occur on national tv during some live tv event?

reply

!!! Warning, this post is full of spoilers, I'd put them all in a 'spoiler' tag but the whole message would be blacked out. !!!


OP I totally agree. Everything about this movie was very nicely made except the most important part, the plot. That absolutely sucked. So badly I could barely watch it. It was very predictable, like an even less scary rehash of 'children of the corn'.

Ethan Hawke was excellent, all the actors did a good job. Except the kids. The kids were so 'not at all scary' they should have been removed from the movie and been totally reworked. For instance, what if they didn't have any lower legs or hands, the legs/arms just gradually turn into mist, so they sorta resemble the stereotypical 'ghost', but with a modern edge. Also it would have been cool if they had a 'super 8' effect applied to only the kids when they're in the scene, so they seem to be displayed at a different frame rate, with dust/scratchs/ticks/pops/etc.

I think what would have made the kids scarier is if they ditched the 'ssssh' pose, which was lame looking, and instead they had really big, cheerful smiles on, sweet and innocent looking, except they're covered in blood and playing with the dead bodies of their family.

I wasn't bothered by the 'tropical animals'... They seemed out of place but a little bit like they were supposed to be. Maybe it would have been better if he keeps finding these creatures in the house(s), in scary places, like the snake crawls out of his pillowcase one night when he lays down to go to sleep. Or he's in the shower, everythings normal, he closes his eyes to rinse out shampoo, and when he opens them again, he's covered in scorpions, the bath tub is full of them, they're everywhere.

The suggestion below is a kinda graphic so i'm wrapping it in a 'spoiler' tag.

Ethan Hawke's character could be giving his wife oral sex, and one of the coral snakes could crawl out of her vagina and into his mouth.

reply

Interesting! But pardon me, what tropical animals were walking around, and what scene? I do remember the dog.

reply

Just some snakes and Scorpions.

Not the second coming of Jumanji otherwise this poster probably would have titled this topic as "Intentionally funny".

reply

If films had to be 100% logical, believable, true, etc, they'd all be terrible and no one would watch them. We get it, you didn't like the film, we get it... there's no reason to point out the obvious plot holes other than to try and make yourself seem smarter.

Most of what makes horror films scary and creepy is the illogical; things that are out of place and don't make sense. People fear what they don't understand and things that don't make sense.

reply

I believe there is a distinction between lazy script and common sense and what it seems illogical. if you are totally out of idea, uninspired and without passion you will write a movie about either mafia or supernatural thriller/horror as these two themes write themselves out. and yes, this is prime example of one.

reply

[deleted]