MovieChat Forums > Unbroken (2014) Discussion > They couldn't find an Italian American t...

They couldn't find an Italian American to play the lead?


Good Lord. Are the Brits taking all the parts? Next thing you know they'll use one to play Martin Luther King Jr. Oh wait.....

reply

need a white LEAD, for funding in this white world.
British actors are making a huge invasion now into hollywood.
many of the leads are going to brits playing americans, ironic isnt it.
you dont see many americans playing brits though

reply

You need a "white lead"? Italians and Italian-Americans ARE white! Perhaps you meant to say "pasty-faced British lead."

reply

Stallone would have been perfect for the lead.

reply

Just be thankful we didn't get Jake Gyllenhaal.

reply

I know, I wanted to see Michael Cera too

reply

It's so common to see non American actors playing Americans and vice versa that I suspect they do it on purpose to create "buzz", just like this thread. They no doubt want to give people one more motivation to see the movie, in this case to see if actor XYZ can "really pull it off", and then to talk about how convincing or UNconvincing their performance was. It's not a new thing in the entertainment industry. The casting of Brits in Gone With The Wind created quite a bit of media chatter and "controversy" in 1938/39, and some people went to see it at least partly for that reason.

reply

Jack is a great actor, and his acting in this movie was amazing. Also...Italians don't have a generic look that they all must meet. 😒 I have a cousin who lives in Italy (she is not Italian, she moved there) and in all the photos she shares with us where she's posing with her friends and co-workers, they look as American as she does.



"One rule: We live or die together." - Joshua Nolan to Irisa Nolan, Defiance

reply

I am an Italian-American myself, and I feel just insulted. They didn't even bother to shoot this movie in Saipan or Japan.

reply

[deleted]

I think that there's something to this.

reply

Meh; Jack O'Connell deserved a break... Arnie would be screwed if there was some sort of rule that you could only play your own nationality - and I didn't see many people complaining that he was Austrian, in his 80's heyday!

Acting is about changing who you are - including perhaps your accent - so it should just be about who conveys the essence of the character best.









"Your mother puts license plates in your underwear? How do you sit?!"

reply

I feel the same as the OP. I would've liked if they got an actual Italian American to play the role. Or at least an American. Nicholas Cage expressed interest in the role years ago. He happens to be Italian American. Too bad he didn't play Louie Zamperini. O'Connell didn't exactly look like Zamperini either. He looked like Kevin Bacon. I also thought it was funny seeing a British actor playing an Italian American war hero and seeing him talking about Italian stuff. Then there's him mentioning gnocchi and saying, "Cara Mama," in the end. I agree 100%. An Italian should've played Zamperini.

Good Lord. Are the Brits taking all the parts? Next thing you know they'll use one to play Martin Luther King Jr. Oh wait.....



The OP is right. It's getting ridiculous now.




reply

Actually, I think that Hollywood film producers will select Tom Hanks, Alan Alda's successor as Hollywood's Number One Mr. Goody-Two-Shoes to portray the late, great Dr. Martin Luther King on screen.

I mean, if a nice liberal actor/comedian like Billy Crystal can portray the late, lamented Sammy Davis, Jr. on SNL, why can't a bona fide Lexus liberal/ President Barack H. Obama sycophant like Tom "Bosom Buddies" Hanks portray Dr. King?

PS If "Unbroken" had been an NBC television movie, the "savants" at that network would have probably cast the "immortal" Richard Grieco or, possibly Mark "Mr. Kelly Ripa" Consuelos (who is actually half Italian-American, I believe) in the role of the truly great and remarkable Mr. Louis Zamperini.

reply