The mosted eff'd up thing you've done in game?

In multiplayer I went to the Hunting Ground with the bobcats in Mexico for the first time. Before this I didn't have much experience with bobcats, so I didn't know what to expect. A pack of them attacked and killed my horse, which made me fall on the ground and then 3 or 4 bobcats ripped me apart in the bushes.

(Spoiler, but not for RDR)
Sort of reminded me of what happened to Eddie Carr in The Lost World novel with the raptors :P

I lassoed the last bigfoot and pulled him behind my horse then killed him

you guys are depressing me. not by how messed up what you guys did was but by how tame most of the things you think are messed up are. your making me feel like a sociopath.

eg only 2 people have mentioned trying to kill abigail and jack, and the truth is the second time i played the game through when i got upto the last mission i decided i didnt wasnt to turn into jack so i killed my family and ran away.
at night i snuck into jacks bedroom crouched down next to his bed and slit his throat, waited for it to restart(it kills you as well) then slit abigails throat as she lay sleeping.


meeting edgar rosses wife i literally beat her off her porch.
i got the info out of her and punched her untill she fell over the railing r whatever then dragged her down to the lake and kicked her into the water to drown

i spent a little while kidnapping women and taking them to the stone circle in mesca...erm the place on the top of the hill between armidillo and macfarlanes ranch put them tied up in the middle of the circle and slit there throats.

when a dude came to me saying his wife was gonna be hung i followed him shot him in the back of the head then killed the bandits and watched the woman hang then after she died i used her swinging body as a punch bag (its actually quite good for it)

when someone offerd me a duel id agree then shoot them in the back

if a dude attacked a whore id stand and watch him stab her then push him out the way to loot the body

i made it a habit to always leave one enemy alive and tie them up and ride around with them on the back of my horse untill i found some inventive way of killing them.


i once killed a posse who were after me tieing up the last guy just before a police dog got to me i shot the dog before it ran away and then carried the dude over to the dog put him down next to it and made him watch me skin his pet less than a foot in front of him before slitting his throat

[deleted]

Every time I duel with someone instead of killing them I disarm them, tie them up and set them on fire (I wish there was a teabag or piss on option so I could show how much I really own them). I lose honor every time too, which sucks because you're allowed to kill them just not that way. I always win it back so it's not like it really matters.

Always when i hogtie someone i put the victim on a horse and i keep riding till i find a rattlesnake then i drop the victim near the rattlesnake that never gets boring 

[deleted]