Let's face it, there aren't many movies set in Alexandria during the late 4th and early 5th centuries, so let's make the most of this one.
There are lots of nagging inaccuracies but other posters have already pointed all these out. So I'm going to comment on the feel. The movie makers brought Alexandria to life much better than I expected. I got the sense of a city always on the edge of rioting, pagan v Christian in the first half and Christian v Jew in the second.
I particularly liked the conversion of the temple into a church, in the second half of the movie. The ancient Egyptian statues were still there but their faces had mostly been hacked away, just like the real life obliteration by early Christians of Egyptian faces on statues at Ramesses III's temple at Medinet Habu. A nice touch.
And I loved the occasional very long shots too, the ones from space.
There will always be inaccuracies in any movie or TV show, but I have a real fondness for Agora. I love antiquity, but it's often glossed over by filmmakers. I mean, I love watching movies and shows set in the Middle Ages or Viking era as much as the next person (I'm particularly fond of Vikings...), but there's just not enough ancient Greek/Roman/Egyptian out there. Unless it's a Christian movie, but then it's focused entirely around either Christ or Old Testament Biblical stories. Sometimes you get a good story about Cleopatra or some Roman emperor, but they almost always feel as though they're playing into the myth more than the reality.
Nothing wrong with them, whether it's a historical drama based around the romance between Cleopatra and Mark Antony (with heavy doses of later Roman propaganda thrown in) or a Christian-based film such as Sampson and Deliah, but we very seldom see films like Agora that provide an interesting snapshot into the lives of people living in an ancient city that's about to be torn asunder by politics and religion.
It would be interesting to see more of these kinds of films. We could get a more accurate portrayal of Cleopatra, or go back further to the time of the great pyramids! Pythagoras had an interesting life - in fact, a lot of philosophers had interesting lives. I wish Hollywood didn't just glance over these ages, but I suppose they find them to be a market risk.
Good thoughts there Shounenbat. I agree we don’t have many movies about antiquity. They come rare these days and the trend will probably go on as scarce since usually they don’t do so well at the box office. This movie bombed because it’s not for an average viewer. I don’t even remember having any ads running during its theater release here in the states. I missed it. But now watched it with great pleasure. Damn sad ending though.
Come to think of it, I don't remember any ads either! Such a shame that there's so little interest in antiquity, especially since Hollywood is so fond of adding filler and twisting things around. They could easily add filler to the lives of these ancient people because it's not like we have a complete enough biography of many of them to cry historical inaccuracy.
There’s another way to get more of ancient Greece goodness though - it’s Assassin’s Creed Odyssey video game. I think it does fairly good job presenting the ancient Greece. At least in an entertaining manner of course. I’m enjoying the game a lot. You might not get the authentic historical accounts there, but it features lots of famous historical characters like Sokrates, Hippokrates, and also lots of mythological creatures like Medusa, Minotaur and others.
"Troy" might be worth a try for you.
It is not a Biblical movie and pretty much removes all the supernatural elements of "The Illiad".
"King Arthur" is set in the era, that is right between Ancient and Medieval times.
But it takes a similar semi-realistic approach to the Arthurian legends.
"Gladiator" is maybe not 100 % historically accurate.
But it's probably the most notable movie about Ancient Rome from the last twenty years.