MovieChat Forums > 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) Discussion > 10 Ungrateful Feminist Lane: A Review

10 Ungrateful Feminist Lane: A Review


10 Cloverfield Lane starts by introducing us to Michelle, a woman in her late 20s who walks out on her boyfriend.

Michelle (Mary Elizabeth Windsor) stops at a gas station, where she looks suspiciously at a truck driver just minding his own business, then clutches her pocketbook until she's done filling her car and leaves.

While she's in the car, her boyfriend Ben calls her. She answers the phone but, despite Ben's pleading, she refuses to talk to him. Ben begs her to say something and says couples fight, it's no big deal, but Michelle cruelly hangs up on him. We don't know what Ben supposedly did, but we're lead to believe that he is a terrible person.

Next, Michelle is texting or something on her phone, and she loses control and crashes down an embankment. She is left there until a mysterious Good Samaritan helps her.

When Michelle wakes up, she immediately becomes panicked. It's clear that she's been rescued by a caring person -- her wounds are tended and bandaged, and she's even got an IV drip. Michelle reaches for the closest comfort item -- her phone. Then when she gets the cell phone the FIRST thing she does -- and I am not making this up -- is take a selfie. She holds the phone up high to shoot at a favorable angle and snaps photos of herself.

Meanwhile we hear someone coming downstairs and it's John Goodman. Instead of saying, "Hey John Goodman, thank you for being a Goodman Samaritan and tending to my wounds!" Michelle is immediately suspicious and thinks John is some sort of pervert who wants to sexually assault her. Already we can see a pattern here -- Michelle thinks everyone is out to kidnap and have sex with her, whether it's her boyfriend, the random truck driver at the gas station, or even John Goodman.

John Goodman spends a lot of time explaining to Michelle that aliens had invaded, and that the air outside wasn't safe because of fallout or chemical weapons. Michelle is lucky to be one of the only survivors, because John Goodman built a bunker and generously took her there when she was knocked out from the car crash.

Michelle also meets Eric, who confirms John Goodman's story.

Yet despite both men telling her the same story, and the evidence of two pigs that have been reduced to bacon by the fallout, Michelle still thinks John Goodman is lying and that he's some sort of perv who wants to keep her there forever living under a patriarchal regime.

Without provocation, Michelle hits John Goodman in the head with a beer bottle, then tries to escape...but just before she opens the hatch door, a zombie woman shows up and starts smashing her head against the glass.

Vindicated, John Goodman doesn't gloat or say "I told you so" to the ungrateful Michelle. He doesn't even hold it against her that she brutally attacked him with a beer bottle. Nope. All he does is ask for her help to sew up his wounds, and Michelle doesn't even want to do it.

After a montage showing us how Michelle, Eric and John Goodman are adjusting to their happy lives and playing Monopoly, the air filtration system breaks and Michelle has to crawl through a duct to a small room where she can restart the air system.

Once there, Michelle finds an earring. Suddenly she's like a CSI investigator, and she makes up this accusation that John Goodman killed and kidnapped girls. She manages to convince Eric that this is true, and the two of them plot to take out John Goodman and claim his bunker for themselves.

I will end my synopsis there and not give away the ending, but suffice to say it's at least another 45 minutes of paranoid delusions about how John Goodman is evil, and Michelle convincing herself that literally everyone else in the movie wants to kidnap her and have sex with her.

Not only is Michelle completely ungrateful to John Goodman, she doesn't even shed a tear for him or feel the slightest pang of guilt when it turns out he was RIGHT about the aliens. He was right all along, he was telling the truth all along, and all he wanted was to nurse her back to health and live as a happy family until the fallout passed.

10 Cloverfield Lane could easily be called 10 Ungrateful Feminist Lane. Over all though, it's good to see directors like JJ Abraham who refuse to give in to the extremist feminist, ultra-liberal thought cartel who insist that all men are somehow evil. For all its infuriating scenes of Michelle thinking the absolute worst of John Goodman, 10 Cloverfield Lane is a powerful story of vindication, showing us John Goodman was right all along.

reply

I can understand what you're trying to do here, but oh my, have you failed misreably and completely missed the point. It seems like you're trying to accuse the film of being misandric.

Micehelle was kidnapped, yes, but it's made clear Goodman tried to save her life, but she blacked out after the accident, then wakes up in a bunker with a strange man she's never seen before, and it seems like you expect her to believe everything she's being told. She didn't. She was scared and wanted out, and to discover if he's telling the truth or not. Dude, this is realism, and there's a difference.

Plus, Emmet was a good guy who sacrificed himself, and maybe you coud accuse of her of being ungrateful and selfish, and perhaps her character is to an extent, but the actress Winstead tends to play characters who are like that anyway. Whenever she plays a woman in turmoil, quite often her character ends up stronger than usual, which is clearly why she was cast in the film.

Now stop ya wining.

reply

You're right, it IS realism -- it shows how angry feminist girls automatically distrust men, even men who are CLEARLY trying to help them and look out for them. No Goodman deed goes unpunished.

I mean, this girl was unbelievable. She gets into an accident because she's texting while driving, she wakes up with her wounds bandaged and an IV set up for her, and the FIRST thing she does is accuse John Goodman of trying to have sex with her.

Then we're supposed to believe this RIDICULOUS conspiracy theory that John Goodman is a killer?

John Goodman should get a t-shirt that says, "I tried to save a feminist's life, and all I got was this lousy cut on my head."

Do you think he WANTED to be stuck in a bomb shelter with an angry feminist when he could be out having a good time and bowling with The Dude and Donnie? No. He did it out of the kindness of his heart, because he KNEW there were aliens invading.

reply

The interesting part of this thread is that there are people who truly do think the way the OP is pretending to.
Response to the OP is less about him getting a laugh out of getting a rise from people, and more about the sad state of some peoples core beliefs.

I guess it could also be viewed as a take on the idea that someone can interpret a story to mean almost anything they want.
Claiming different motives, and deep symbolism.

The OP fails in his attempt however, because he presents unfactual points about the story.

reply

Ben begs her to say something and says couples fight, it's no big deal, but Michelle cruelly hangs up on him. We don't know what Ben supposedly did, but we're lead to believe that he is a terrible person.


Well she wanted to leave him so he must be terrible, he must have done something wrong.

Or just not have enough ambition etc

What a loser.

reply

Considering all the sexual assaults and rapes that happen these days, I would gave been the same way if I were a girl in that situation. Hell, i don't trust strangers now that much. You don't know who the hell someone is in today's world. And also, if I'm a girl and i wake up in a locked room chained to the *beep* wall, im gonna start thinking that this guy has me here for a few certain reasons.

Her reactions were pretty rational one's. Considering the fact she was being held against her will the entire time.

Enough with this feminism over reaction bullcrap. Its all I see on forums for movie's with female leads. Its getting ridiculous.

Now that I have my coffee, I'm ready to watch radar

reply

@X-TheEliminator


And also, if I'm a girl and i wake up in a locked room chained to the *beep* wall, im gonna start thinking that this guy has me here for a few certain reasons.



You're damn right about that. That's exactly the first thing that the average woman would be thinking about in that situation. I'm a woman, and I for damn sure would be. The OP (who clearly isn't a woman) obviously has no concept or clue of how a women would act in real life in a situation like that, and the very real and frightening dangers being in a situation like that could pose. Also, every time I've heard or someone being locked up a in a basement in real life on the news, it was always to keep that person prisoner, and the person was being held prisoner by a psycho or a criminal, like those three girls who were held captive in that house in Cleveland by that nutcase for over a decade. So the OP is basically just stupid, immature as hell, young, and an idiot to think a woman is supposed to be "grateful" for being basically held captive to some extent by anybody. And usually people who rant against feminism don't even know or understand what the hell it really is anyway, and haven't even bothered to find out what it means half the damn time.


Also, women have been starring in action films since films were invented, so his shows just how ridiculous the OP's posts is. Considering that the majority of action films feature and star mainly men, complaining about ONE or a handful of films that feature women in the lead for a change is just damn plain stupid as hell to me.


reply

Quite easily the most inane review of the movie I have ever read.

reply

This is hilarious! Thank you OP for illustrating just how stupid most of the people (those replying to you as if you are serious) on these boards are.

That IS a tasty burger!

reply

Not quite as funny as he thinks he is but yeah, not a bad first attempt. He should have just left it at that though. His follow up replies are just lame now.

reply

Some people...

reply