MovieChat Forums > Definitely, Maybe (2008) Discussion > Emily , April or Summer

Emily , April or Summer

posted 17 years ago by stevenmcpunisher
119 replies | jump to latest

Who would you have picked. Peronally i think ending up with April was the right choice.

[–] ChristianWoolf 11 years ago

April for sure. A girl like her is hard to find.

Straight Edge is the only way to be free.
Rachel Weisz FOR Catwoman!

[–] eddiewinehosen 9 years ago

April, first and only fictional character that I fell in love with.

[–] sunchick116-872-583383 8 years ago

Should have been April from the beginning. Who marries a cheater?

[–] eddiewinehosen 8 years ago

Agree, I can overlook most other character flaws but that's a deal breaker.

[–] freebird1987 8 years ago

April

[–] madduxcyyoung4 8 years ago

Out of those 3, I'd probably pick April as well. If Emily cheated on me, she'd be completely out of the picture...I couldn't trust her anymore. Summer would be soooo tempting....I've always found Rachel Weisz to be such a gorgeous woman. But April is very beautiful as well, plus she just seems like the one I'd have the most in common with.

Of course knowing my luck....I'd be stuck in the friend zone with April and completely hung up on Summer...and completely miserable.

"Thank you very much you son of a bitch"--Stone Cold Steve Austin

[–] jmr61 8 years ago

April.

Case closed.

[–] davidjanuzbrown 8 years ago

April is the easy choice. Not only because Isla was the hottest of the three, but because she accepted Will unconditionally and that means Maya who is a part of his life ( especially because Maya really comes first in his life). The way they held hands at the end showed that they will have no trouble bonding.

[–] Hans-Wilhelm (1365) 6 years ago

April.
Neither of the other two would I have ever considered. (Of course, after knowing about the affair with the woman he married).