MovieChat Forums > Alita: Battle Angel (2019) Discussion > Captain Marvel was way better

Captain Marvel was way better


some like to claim that this movie was targeted in order to bash it so that it didn't post a threat to Captain Marvel but seriously this movie just couldn't compete.

reply

I liked both movies. Both had strong female leads.

reply

I enjoyed both. Alita could've been much better with more polish to the script and pacing imo.

Shame the filmmakers wanted to make a sequel but it doesn't seem like it's happening due to lower-than-expected box office returns.

reply

"due to lower-than-expected box office returns"

Because it couldn't compete with Captain Marvel.

reply

I think even if you take Captain Marvel out of the discussion, Alita had a rather enormous budget ($170+ million) and marketing campaign. James Cameron was even on talk shows and Youtube videos promoting it.

The movie did a very decent $405 million according to BoxOfficeMojo. But considering no sequel has been officially announced, and movie theaters also get a sizable chunk of that $405 million take, 20th Century Fox (well, now Disney) may not have broken even or made a profit. Or if they did, it was probably right on the edge. Studios look for significant profit/audience enthusiasm in order to greenlight sequels. I enjoyed the movie and wouldn't mind sequels to it, but I just don't think it made enough.

https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt0437086/

reply

I don't know about that. Pacific Rim did similar numbers ($180 million budget with $411 million worldwide gross) and it got a sequel.

reply

I enjoyed both Both were in my top 10 of 2019

reply

And I’ll say it again: “Nobody ever went broke by underestimating the taste of the American public.” - H.L. Mencken. The only thing that popularity necessarily demonstrates is that something is popular, not that it is good. The OP needs to provide a cogent argument defending why Capt. Marvel is, objectively, the better film. I’m not going to hold my breath. And “There’s never been one more beautiful” ain’t gonna cut it.

reply

[deleted]

👍👍👍👍👍👍

reply

Honestly while Captain Marvel wasn't as bad as all those alt-right Youtubers claimed, I enjoyed this far more. It was stranger, the action was cooler, and although I like Brie Larson fine, Rosa Salazar's character was more interesting.

reply

Lol I never understood why SJW's were so threatened by Alita, probably because it negates their 'men hate women in movies' false narrative 🤣.

reply