MovieChat Forums > Lost (2004) Discussion > Is LOST the greatest television series o...

Is LOST the greatest television series of all times?


Thoughts?

reply

No.

Lost had possibly the greatest pilot episode of all time, and its first season stands as one of the all time best. But as a whole it is not the greatest show of all time. I think it suffered from being a network show, in that it was forced to do 22 episodes every year, which lead to a lot filler episodes, and questions being created and forgotten about. I believe it was season 4, where due to the writers strike was only 14 episodes, and was actually really good, and didn't waste time on pointless plots, like Jack's tattoos.

Also at times it was very clear that the writers had no idea how long the show was going to go for. Even if they did know how they wanted it to end, they didn't know how long to drag things out for. This was very clear during season 3. Near the end of that season they announced the show would run 3 more years and things for the most part were better after that. But the last season still kind of sucked.

Lost was a great show, with many great episodes and amazing moments, but I would not consider it the greatest of all time.

reply

Agree, the first couple of seasons were great, but then it went off on too many directions and lasted too long. I think it should have been told in 3 or 4 season at the max. After season 4, I lost interest and stopped watching because I no longer cared what happened.

reply

I actually find Season 4 worse than anything that came before it and the shortening of the later seasons didn´t really benefit LOST at all. I´d take 1,2,3 over 4,5,6 every day of the week. There were some really great filler episodes in the earlier seasons even though they were obvious filler. No, I don´t mean Jack´s tattoos but episodes like Tricia Tanaka is Dead, The Long Con etc. I think what really kills LOST for being an all time great show is season 6. It´s just so awful. The flash sideways was just an uninteresting waste of time that had no bearing on the end of the show.

reply

One of the greatest

reply

Not even close, this thing falls apart after the 3rd season.

reply

Was it ever actually together? I caught on after a couple episodes that it would never go any where, just jacking around to try to seem interesting. Just another endless soap opera

reply

True, the show really felt like they were making it up as it went along.

reply

It was definitely spinning it's wheels.

I think when ABC gave them a definitive time table on when to wrap things up they got on track, and I do think the basic idea of what LOST was and how it would end was a story they had in mind from the beginning. Though several storylines had a lot of buildup and promise but no payoff.

Not to mention the filler.

Plenty of that.

reply

It's BY FAR the greatest television drama of all time.

Not to mention it's objectively leaps and bounds better than embarrassingly overrated tripe like the one about pathetic italian gangsters, the medieval murder-porn incest nonsense, and especially the "comedy-drama" about the drug lord with cancer which completely failed at comedy AND drama.

reply

Not even close. Which is a shame because the series got off to an excellent start with a very solid first season. But the show's second season made a huge decline with the awful casting of Michelle Rodriguez and poor pacing and repetitive storytelling that just dragged on and on. The show made a slight rebound in its third and fourth seasons but just grew too convoluted in its last two seasons. That said, I did think the series finale was emotionally satisfying.

This series would have benefited from an extreme trim, as it probably should have run no more than 4 seasons with 13 to 16 episodes each season.

Season 1 - 8/10
Season 2 - 6/10
Season 3 - 7/10
Season 4 - 7/10
Season 5 - 6/10
Season 6 - 6/10

reply

Funny. For me the show became better when this awful Maggie Grace left...

reply

It's certainly my favorite TV series of all time. But after I saw this show and talked to people about it, clearly opinions differ... big time.

reply

Dramatic series...yes!

reply