MovieChat Forums > The Island (2005) Discussion > This is Just an Updated Version of Logan...

This is Just an Updated Version of Logan's Run


Is it me, or is this movie basically Logan's Run? Live a few years in perfect harmony and go on Carousel I mean to the Island. Unless you and Jessica escape and eventually free all of the others? The only real difference is the organ harvesting/child bearing aspect. Still enjoyed it though. Love Steve Buscemi!

reply

It wreaks of Logan's Run

Society controlled under an illusion.

The Lottery ceremony to the Island but really toward their death = Carousel ceremony to Renewal but really to their death.

Censors = Sandmen (even the costumes look similar).

One guy questions the status quo. A triggering event/senerio causes him to run. He takes a female companion. They get chased. There is even sexual chemistry between the two. They discover the truth and go back to free the others. They all head to freedom in the end under explosions and destruction. Accompanied by a glorious soundtrack.

Totally!!



I am the Alpha and the Omoxus. The Omoxus and the Omega

reply

While it does have some similarity to Logan's Run, it's more of a remake of 'The Clonus Horror'. It's plot is basically identical.

reply

THanks man took me like 20 minutes to find the name... "Logan's Run" Surprisingly no similarity results on google!? Saw that with my dad a long ass time ago...

reply

[deleted]

I can see that with THX1138 and the animated show Aeon Flux with a bit of Ghost in the Shell.

"If this is torture, chain me to the wall"-Oliver and Company

reply

The Island is like 2 movies glued together. The first part is almost identical to The Clonus Horror, the second part is almost identical to Logan's Run. This was discussed a lot back in 2005 when this movie was in theaters.

reply

Both films are 10/ 10



(RIP Peter Ustinov and Farrah Fawcett)




Smoke me a kipper. I'll be back for breakfast

reply

Yes it sort of is. It's actually a mash up of four previous movies:

Logan's Run
THX-1138
The Matrix
Blade Runner





Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar and doesn't.

reply

Nothing original under the sun! Well maybe there are some totally original ideas but some of them are really crappy. Lots of stories are another imagining by someone of the same "what if?"s. I'd prefer this kind of remake to 'let's do a remake/sequel of what we just did', like all the superman/spiderman/batman movies. But obviously many people like those too. Just keep 'em coming! :)

reply