MovieChat Forums > Batman Begins (2005) Discussion > The judge asking for a statement from a ...

The judge asking for a statement from a member of the Wayne family


"I gather a member of the Wayne family is here today. Does he have anything to say?"

Do judges really do this; ask for a member of the victim's family to say something? If Bruce had stood up and said he objected to Chill's early release, would the court have taken that into account?

reply

Bump.

reply

Bump.

reply

Faden was revealed to be a crooked judge, so he likely didn't care about propriety one way or the other.

reply

True, that.

reply

Not sure what type of hearing this was supposed to be but parole boards do take victim's statements into account.

reply

Good point.

reply

Since it was an early release as part of a deal, absolutely judges can take a family members statement into account. That doesn't mean they will, but they can. A judge can actually reject a deal if he deems it not fair or wrong. So had Bruce spoken, the judge definitely could have taken into account and kept Chill in prison to serve his full sentence.

Now as someone pointed out the judge was corrupt and was going to let Chill go no matter what so Falcone could kill him, but if we pretend he wasnt corrupt for arguments sake, he could take Bruce's statement into account.

reply

yes, all the time. family members are also invited to speak when judges are sentencing criminals, particularly in death penalty cases.

reply

Yes, family members testify at sentencing proceedings all the time. They don't really influence the court's decision, as the judge already knows what he will do by that point. But it gives the family members some mental comfort to speak in open court that way, on the record

reply