MovieChat Forums > Shallow Hal (2001) Discussion > plus Size woman can be attractive

Yeah...

No.

reply

Yeah

Yes

Those tits and ass

reply


There's enough ass for three women there.

reply

And i love it

reply

Of course they can. Its just a silly but funny movie

reply

20-30 years ago, thin was in. People like curvy better now.

reply

I agree with u!
But unfortunately people like her won't be considered as hot or pretty by the majority.

reply

A lot of them have terrible taste in women

reply

Ashely Graham, Latecia Thomas, Ashleigh Dunn, Shelby Fetterman and Sharon Grobben have all been linked too this thread to counteract the arguement that plus size can be attractive compared to the way we are looking at the character in Shallow Hal.

However none of this women are anywhere near as fat as Rosemary so that argument doesn't really work, the women listed are bigger then what's perceived as 'normal size' yes and attractive but nowhere as huge as Rosemary, try and at least show a comparison with someone as obese as Rosemary then we can have that discussion.

reply

Thanks for the bump

reply

Your welcome, try and list some really obese women like Rosemary that are as attractive as Ashley so we can get some proper comparisons, not just plus size models.

reply

Nothing wrong with my posts

reply

Well you've posted about plus size women being hot with a link to Ashley in a thread about Shallow Hall where the woman is obese.
If it had no relevance to the film then you could of just said Ashley was hot in her own thread/forum but you chose to put it here as a comparison but it really has nothing to do with comparing an obese woman to a plus size model so yes thee is something wrong with your post.

reply

Nope

reply

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

What you find attractive someone else doesn't. What is wrong with that?

Or do you just want everyone to agree with you.

From the picture she seems alright and i'm sure she is a nice enough person. Personally not my type.

Now you will reply with something derogatory about my type but there in lays the problem. You do not speak for everyone and so i end this statement with how i started.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

reply

90 pound blonde skeletons aren't hot

reply

Your opinion

reply

Nope its facts nothing attractive about a woman who starves herself

reply

90 pound blonde skeletons aren't hot


That is an opinion. Not fact

reply

Well said

reply

Ok, but the Rosemary is twice her size in this movie. I like thick women, not walking bags of cellulite.

reply

Ashley Graham keeps getting thicker and looks good

reply