That's a good analogy, and something of how I picture it. One of the things I like about Star Wars' approach to religion (not to directly talk about it except through "the Force" and the Jedi) is that we get a sense of what these religious groups are like, but nothing seems like a 1:1 with our world. In other words, the Jedi aren't an allegory for the Knights Templar. Because, although the parallels you pointed out ring true, it's also worth noting that the Knights Templar were annihilated from within their religion (the Church) while Order 66 had a political origin. Or, at the very least, was from a Sith, not higher Jedi.
We get to have some parallels and similarities, particularly with Buddhism, Taoism, and other Eastern religions; the Jedi are very much mystical samurai, influenced by Kurosawa's films. However, those parallels don't overwhelm the lore and make us go, "Oh, so they're basically Taoists." (Or whichever religion).
This, to me, is what makes the spiritual aspects of Star Wars fun to discuss and contemplate, and what makes them so wonderful in terms of the world-building. Contrast this to something like the Magisterium in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series (which I admittedly only know about from The Golden Compass film). That's a direct 1:1 with the Catholic Church and is designed to criticize Catholicism. To me, that has always made that world (again, in the film) seem "small" somehow. Not only is it engaging only with one aspect of one religion (Catholicism in Christianity) it's also there explicitly to make a counter-claim and critique that aspect.
The Jedi are more general, more diverse in their origins, and are given lauds and judgments throughout the series. Far more fun to discuss later.
reply
share