I know it's based on a book but here's my issue with it. The going to war scenes in Vietnam were incredible and a more serious tone developed within the film. As with the meeting of ''Lieutenant Dan'' in NYC again portraying him as a broken man hammered by war made the film go in the direction of a drama.
Sadly this didn't last long as the film started getting silly again with ridiculous things like running across America because he got a new pair of shoes, Forrest inventing the ''smiley face'' sticker and Forest buying stock in apple. It goes on and and on. Even the interjection of AIDS and death of his sweetheart couldn't bring back the proper drama aspect scene in the earlier half of the film.
That is my main issue with the film. You have some great drama aspects buried within it but an overwhelming amount of silliness taking away that part of the films merit.
I think there are a lot of issues with the movie and I get your points. For me, I enjoy this movie because of the music. The songs that were picked; the scenes over which they were played; what snippets of the songs to use...it's great stuff if you're a music fan like I am.
I've never seen "Elizabethtown," but yes, I really do like "Almost Famous" a lot and "Fast Times At Ridgemont High" as well. I agree that Cameron Crowe seems to have a great ear for music.
Forrest Gump is a 'life story' movie so naturally it combine sadness, humor, silliness moments, serious scenes and more light ones. As life itself it's a roller coaster of emotions - It's part of the genre rules. Forrest Gump is in my top 10 movies of all time and I enjoy every scene, although the same as you, I loved a little more the dramatic aspects of the movie but even they have small comedy moments. I am not agree with your argument that "drama aspects buried" between "overwhelming amount of silliness", it's more drama movie with little raindrops of heartwarming silliness scattered around.
Excellent post. I'm reminded of a story my dad told me of what he saw at a wake (viewing) back in the 50s. A woman sitting in one of the rows was overcome with grief and was losing control. While flailing her arms she ended up slapping a bald guy sitting right in front of her at least twice with a loud "thwack".
My dad was sitting towards the back of the room and had to run out because he was stifling a laugh and was afraid of bursting out.
Even in times of sadness, humorous things can happen.
Good thing your dad ran out, seems like a really funny situation that it's hard to hold yourself from laughing. Mainly the contrast between the seriousness of the mourning ceremony and the comic situation.
If you think those things are too silly, you should read the book. The book's premise after he gets home from Vietnam make everything you complain about seem like everyday normal things. Just go read the book and you'll appreciate this film way more.
Edit: If you don't want to read the book. Here is a copy of my post on another topic on this board. And there will be major spoilers of the book in it for anyone that's interested in reading the book. You probably aren't though. And I am not joking about any of this or making it up. It actually happens in the book. I also added extra stuff that wasn't in my original post.
Like Forrest getting in trouble with the law and going on a space mission for NASA to avoid prison time then crashlanding his ship on an island full of Cannibals. Then becomes friends with the Cannibal King who is a Yale graduate who teaches Forrest to play Chess.
Then after living with the Cannibals for 4 years he gets rescued and upon getting back meets Jenny and Lieutenant Dan again and becomes a wrestler called the Dunce.
Then when that doesn't work out he goes to Los Angelus where he both enters a Chess Competition and gets to film a scene in a Creature from the Black Lagoon movie with Rachelle Welch which doesn't work out doing the movie cause he takes Rachelle Whelch too far into the swamp and her clothes get completely torn off so he gets to carry her naked through a swamp, and a highway til he gets to a clothing store where he and Rachelle Welch get arrested by the cops cause of her being naked and Forrest looking creepy in a Creature from the Black Lagoon costume.
Then after getting out of jail by the guy who put him in the chess competition. He goes to said competition but makes the mistake of bringing his orangutan he's friends with (I didn't mention that part. He meets said orangutan when going into outerspace earleir in the book and its with him when he is on the island full of cannibals) until the ape goes berskek thus ruining the chess competition.
His rich friend who put him in that chess competition gives him a plane ride back to his homestate of Alabama where he finally creates his Shrimping Company by getting almost every person he's ever met to help farm shrimp until he needs help keep track of finances. Rachelle Welch even does ads for his company.
Then he runs for Congress with the Campaign slogan, "I gotta pee! After reading all that, you can probably guess why the film isn't like this. It's very ridiculous and it's obvious the author ran out of good plausible ideas halfway through and just said, "The hell with it! I'm gonna make this so ridiculous it's over the top and entertaining!" Oh and neither Jenny or his mom die in the book either.
I have no issues with the film. I think it has a perfect mix of tone. Itβs brilliant, and itβs one of my all time favorite movies. I could watch it every day.
I believe that the serious moments are made more poignant by the interwoven light scenes. Also, there's so much seriousness a cinema-goer can take before becoming overwhelmed by it.