MovieChat Forums > Forrest Gump (1994) Discussion > Forrest vs. Pulp vs. Shawshank

Forrest vs. Pulp vs. Shawshank


Which movie do you think is the best of '94? The Shawshank Redemption, Pulp Fiction, or Forrest Gump? In my opinion, it's Forrest Gump.

reply

For me personally I like Shawshank Redemption the best.
All three are quite entertaining. I think S.R. is one of the best films of all times.
One of the cases where I like the movie more than the book (or novella in this case). The Novella was nice but the film was great in my opinion.

reply

Shawshank. While not original or groundbreaking, it's framing of a mix of other elements makes it much more enjoyable in comparison to the stories it draws from.

Pulp Fiction is a bore. Unless you really like that Tarantino vibe or have a thing for romanticizing junkie culture, it has little to offer. For my part, Tarantino has a couple of interesting film but none of them have a lot of rewatch value and Pulp Fiction is at the bottom of the list.

Forrest Gump is mostly a one trick pony; A really ignorant guy being placed in the middle of extraordinary circumstances and coming out looking good by sheer dumb luck. Aside from that there's a couple of hum-drum subplots, the most memorable of which is Lt. Dan. While it's a good subplot it's not really better or more compelling than any in Shawshank which also leans heavily on these devices to propel the story.

reply

If you think the movie Forrest Gump has extraordinary circumstances you should read the book. I like the movie and book. But some of the stuff that happens in the book is so unbelievable it makes the movie look like a historical documentary by comparison

reply

Do you think the book adds more depth to Gump or is it just more of the same?

reply

Not really. Gump cusses a lot in the book and says a lot of inappropriate things.

reply

LOL. That could be entertaining.

reply

You want us to say TSR. Gump here.

reply

Pulp Fiction is overrated what as hell.

reply

Pulp Fiction. Forrest Gump never should have been Oscar material.

reply

1.) Shawshank
2.) Forrest Gump
3.) Speed



?.) Pulp Fiction

reply