MovieChat Forums > Friends (1994) Discussion > Should there have been a black "Friend"?

Should there have been a black "Friend"?


If it were made today there would have been.

Blacks are about 13% of the American population. One sixth is about 17%.

It seems only logical one of them would have been black. So why not?

reply

Not every white person has a black friend. It's just the way it is.

reply

For the same reason Craig and DayDay didn't have a white hombre.

reply

Who cares.
Get out of here with your identity politics garbage.

reply

Uh, you're the one trying to make this political. I'm just noting the difference between 2022 and 30 years ago.

reply

If you think every show that has six main characters must have a minority as a main character or else something is "wrong" or "out of place" then that just shows how badly your thinking is warped and you are the type just looking for something to upset you.

reply

You have a problem with reading comprehension. I'm fine with 6 white friends. But I'm saying if this show was made today one of the six would have been black. I'm not endorsing that. I'm not against it. It's just the times in which we live.

reply

Given the quirkiness of the group I would think an Asian friend would fit the dynamic better.

reply

The all white crowd scenes in restaurants, sidewalks, coworkers, etc. in diverse New York City were completely unrealistic. Seinfeld showed realistic diversity and was funnier.

reply

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAnvn25URvc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3S517s7E4wk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVpDowulBgQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISCrrkSg8Zw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N3IV7ZJkmj0

AS CHANDLER WOULD SAY....COULD YOU BE ANY MORE WRONG?!

reply

Tokenism isn't diversity. The creator apologized about the lack of diversity:
https://nypost.com/2022/06/29/friends-creators-4m-apology-for-lack-of-diversity/

Seinfeld had old, middle-aged, young adults and children, skinny and obese, people in wheelchairs, using canes, deaf, blind, bald and hairy, gay and straight, and plenty of ethnic and racial diversity with and without speaking roles. They also addressed various bigotry in a bold and realistic way.

Friends had an Italian stereotype. Tsk, tsk!
At least, Seinfeld had an overweight, bald guy who was realistically neurotic. Real people represented.

reply

NO...NOT TOKENISM...VISIBLE DIVERSITY IN CROWDS AND AMONGST EXTRAS...PERHAPS NOT ENOUGH TO REFLECT REALITY...BUT IT IS THERE NONTHELESS...ALSO...SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT SEINFELD...NOBODY SAID ANYTHING ABOUT SEINFELD BUT YOU.🙂

reply

"PERHAPS NOT ENOUGH TO REFLECT REALITY"

That's called Tokenism.

Never! Seinfeld is the better show.

reply

NO...THAT'S CALLED TOKENISM NOW...MODERN DAY...BY BUTTDIGGERS LIKE YOURSELF...THE 90'S WERE A WHILE AGO AND IT WAS UNCOMMON TO FIND A REALITY BASED DIVERSITY ON TELEVISION...BUT FRIENDS IS NO MORE GUILTY THAN ANY OTHER SHOW OF THE ERA...IN FACT...AFTER SCRUBBING THROUGH A FEW EPISODES BASED ON YOUR POST...FRIENDS HAVE A DECENT AMOUNT OF BACKGROUND DIVERSITY...SEINFELD IS A BETTER SHOW...BUT THAT IS NOT THE POINT HERE.

reply

Seinfeld had diversity. Same era.

"BACKGROUND DIVERSITY"
Nope. Seinfeld had diversified characters with speaking roles interacting with the group.

The creator apologized about the lack of diversity:
https://nypost.com/2022/06/29/friends-creators-4m-apology-for-lack-of-diversity/
She says you're wrong.

reply

I AM GOING TO STOP TALKING TO YOU...YOU SEEM UNABLE TO GRASP ANYTHING I AM SAYING TO YOU...BYE BYE.

reply

We were never "talking".

You're not too bright, are you?

reply

🙄

reply

Are you going to respond with emojis in the future? It is much more tranquil than your All Cap responses.

reply

NOW THAT YOU DECIDED TO RESPOND IN ONLY EMOJI, I WILL RESPOND IN ALL CAPS!!!!!!!

reply

DID YOU INTEND TO GIVE ME A BONER?...IF SO...MISSION ACCOMPLISHED.

reply

NO!...BUT ENJOY!!!!!

YOU'RE WELCOME!!!!!!!!!!!

reply

The episode names would have been hilarious.

The One Where Ross Gets Carjacked

The One Where Joeys Tv Gets Stolen

reply

The One Where Black Friend Gets Beaten by Bigots

The One Where Black Friend Is Falsely Arrested After Meeting a Karen

The One Where Black Friend Is Not Promoted Because of Racism

The One Where Black Friend Is Denied An Apartment Because of Racist Landlord

The One Where Insensitive White Friends Do Micro-Aggressions Against Black Friend And Tell Him He's Being Too Sensitive When He Complains

reply

White people have the most in common with other white people and that's who they'd likely be friends with. The creators write from the experiences that they live. Racist liberals seem too stupid understand that.

reply

yes there would be tokens if made today. but I thinks it makes sense for races to have their own show rather than tokens.

like Fresh Prinse of Bell Air. Great shows, all blacks.

Friends. All whites.

I believes white and black in americas prefer to be among there owns.

forcing whites to have black in everythings they make create problems for boths race as black and white hate each other in americas.

reply