The problem I have is a lot of the arc seemed to be written on the fly - I suppose you can't plan everything and some things need to change e.g. when Gillian Anderson became pregnant, David leaving etc. But I did get the feeling as the show went on that not much was planned. I remember the last few series tried to go one step further and have it so that everything we'd seen was lies, the aliens weren't real and just the government, something they have done before, and I think changed on both times.
Yep. This has been driving me nuts. I've just been watching the series through for the first time ever, never saw the show before this year, and I loved the mythology episodes for the first few seasons but, as it went on, it felt like they really fumbled it. Badly. They kept walking back on things that had previously been established (worst of all with the fate of Mulder's sister, the "conclusion" of which was so stupid and contradictory that it nearly ruined the whole series for me), and the whole thing just felt so poorly planned and convoluted that it felt like they were making it up as they were going along. Again, I loved the mythology arc early on, but later it just got kinda ruined IMO.
I also think they made a mistake by going into too much detail about the aliens and the conspiracy and whatnot. It removed a lot of the mystique, and put the writers in a position where they would have to commit to things that they obviously weren't willing to commit to.
reply
share