I've never treated you like a hooker
I'm confused in this scene when Edward says I never treated you like a hooker and Vivian says you just did. How did he treat her like a hooker?
shareI'm confused in this scene when Edward says I never treated you like a hooker and Vivian says you just did. How did he treat her like a hooker?
shareEdward wanted to put Vivian up at an apartment instead of making a commitment and living together. Basically, she felt that she was being asked to be his personal hooker that he can visit any time and have sex with.
shareWhat Delta said. It baffled me too and then, I paid closer attention to what was going on between them.
shareI'm confused as well because he DID treat her like a hooker. That's what the entire movie was about - why he HIRED her, paid her, and was willing to let her go because she was an "employee". Ridiculous. Of course he treated her like one, right from the beginning. 😝
shareHe says 'prostitute' rather than hooker, at least in the UK version. I think it has zero to do with paying her to stay in the hotel and everything to do with the fact that word was still in his mind as to what she was. He was her prince - the only word starting with p that should have been in his mind in all the possible ways you could think of her was 'princess'.
shareThis is how the scene went down:
He had offered her an apartment, extra cash, and cell # he could be reached at, etc.
She hesitantly responded something along the lines of "it's a pretty sweet offer for a girl like me."
His response was "I've never treated you like a prostitute."
That's when she said "you just did."
The way I interpreted it was that when she said "a girl like me" she meant a poor, uneducated woman living on her own working day to day. But all Edward could see is the 'prostitute', hence his response.
The sad thing about this whole scenario is: why does prostitution roll-off as such a negative in this context? I mean, given the set-up he is offering prostitution is actually excellent treatment. It's only in their MINDS that being treated "like a prostitute" definitively equals being treated somehow badly.
It would have been better if he had said, "...I've never treated you badly."
On November 6, 2012 god blessed America...again.
I was a little confused but I always thought it must be the point, when he says I've never treated u like a prostitute, bang right there, that line... was when he did, by saying it or maybe I'm not right..
shareYeah, that was it. When she said, "You just did" she was referring to him saying he never treated her like a prostitute. I personally thought she was acting pretty high and mighty given she was, in fact, a prostitute.
shareI personally thought she was acting pretty high and mighty given she was, in fact, a prostitute.Ha! Boom! There you have it! I mean what is he supposed to do for the rest of their relationship? Never use the word 'prostitute' again? Avoid risking her having to acknowledge the manner in which she has come to live in his benefaction of luxury?
I thought it had to do with the fact that he didn't ask her what she wanted. He told her he had made arrangements for an apartment and for money, assuming that she wanted to have that from him. She was still going to be his "beck and call girl ", and he assumed she would be fine with that.
shareIt’s very difficult because actually she would be moving up to a mistress or courtesan—but that’s where she’d stay. She’d have to be available to him for paying attention to him, lavishing affection upon him.
Pretty soon she might turn to substance abuse. Maybe not thus character, but some people
might.
The whole movie he is always looking at people and things as objects. He slowly starts to appreciate her for her. Instead of treating her like a girlfriend or a person even in the end he still treated her like an object with his offer.
share