MovieChat Forums > Day of the Dead (1985) Discussion > dr. logan didn't turn into a zombie?

dr. logan didn't turn into a zombie?


I thought in Romero's films, anyone whose brain stays intact returns in zombie form? He was shot across the chest. What gives?

"I can't help but notice that there are skulls all over everything. Are we the baddies?"

reply

Anyone who dies in Romero's movies comes back as a zombie as long as their brain is intact... Expect Dr. Logan of course.

While Romero's movies are loose sequels, they are set in the same universe with the same rules.

It is stated in the first film that recently dead, but necessarily bitten, reanimate. This makes sense since there is a bacteria or virus that has spread over earth from some origin.. whether you believe the Venus probe explanation or not doesn't matter, just know that there is some sort of disease out there. This disease reanimates already dead people. It makes sense since a living person doesn't just become a zombie without incident.. So the first zombie had to be something that was dead and obviously unbitten.

A zombie bite itself does not turn a person into a zombie. The infection of the bite kills the person then after death, the person reanimates.. since all dead people reanimate.

The first movie states that this is the case, and as stated by Romero and the general consensus of the movies is that all of the Dead movies are in the same universe and therefore follow the same rules.

I also believe that there are incidents in other Dead movies in which characters who are not bit come back to life, but I can't remember off the top of my head.

reply

It is stated in the first film that recently dead, but necessarily bitten, reanimate. This makes sense since there is a bacteria or virus that has spread over earth from some origin.. whether you believe the Venus probe explanation or not doesn't matter, just know that there is some sort of disease out there. This disease reanimates already dead people. It makes sense since a living person doesn't just become a zombie without incident.. So the first zombie had to be something that was dead and obviously unbitten.


It never says recently bitten. It just says persons who had recently died and what they called the unburied dead. There's even a part in one of the newscasts, where this guy from a college talks about a limbless cadaver that reanimated at his school. This is re-affirmed in Land of the Dead, when the old man in Fidder's Green turns into a zombie. He wasn't a bite victim.

I don't get where this bite business comes from in regards to the Romero dead movies. In those movies, a bite would kill you, but it wasn't the cause of the reanimation. I guess there's other zombie movies where the person is only affected if they are bitten? I know that's not the case with TWD. I guess I'll have to pay more attention, because it probably varies. What people forget about the Romero movies is that a supernatural element was hinted as a possibility, but never fully explored. Not so much the first one, but definitely the second and third movies. This is reflected by the speeches of Peter in Dawn and John in Day. At the end of the day, the cause is irrelevant because some higher power is behind it.

reply

"It is stated in the first film that recently dead, but necessarily bitten, reanimate"

I meant "but NOT necessarily"

Can't seem to edit my post on my phone.

reply

I always took Logan's failure to reanimate as a sign that the virus was winding down. In the original script a character dies and still has not come back several days later, giving the survivors hope. Maybe Romero meant to allude to that via Logan.

reply

"I always took Logan's failure to reanimate as a sign that the virus was winding down. In the original script a character dies and still has not come back several days later, giving the survivors hope. Maybe Romero meant to allude to that via Logan."

I may be wrong, but I'm sure something along these lines was talked about in the audio commentary on my day of the dead DVD.

so that would back up this theory.


and just to chime in on the bite issue....

all dead bodies reanimate in Romero's zombie universe, unless the brain is destroyed.
a zombie bite just kills you, it doesn't directly turn you into a zombie.

the world has undergone some change where the dead no longer stay dead.


My cat can eat a whole watermelon!

reply

I always took Logan's failure to reanimate as a sign that the virus was winding down. In the original script a character dies and still has not come back several days later, giving the survivors hope. Maybe Romero meant to allude to that via Logan.


To elaborate on this, if Logan didn't reanimate, then his body (along with the bodies of Miller and Johnson) were probably consumed by the zombie invasion that overtook the complex.

reply

[deleted]

Isn't it simply possible that Logan was hit in the head and we didn't see it?

reply

Spent ages writing a long replay then the page crashed but here goes.

Yeah Logan could’ve been hit in the head or he reanimated later.

It IS the Romero lore that the bodies of the dead get up and kill whether bitten or not, it’s the case in ALL of the films, the fact that people are arguing this baffles me.

It’s stated on the tv by the scientists in Dawn, the bodies of the recently deceased must be destroyed.

reply