MovieChat Forums > The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1985) Discussion > The Resident Patient...WORST ACTING in t...

The Resident Patient...WORST ACTING in the series


I love all of the episodes, from the Adventures, to Return, to the Casebook, and Memoirs, even (most) of the movies. I can throw in a disc and be entertained just by Brett...Fantastic. All of the episodes are superbly acted...excted one.
The Resident Patient. I love the beginning with Holmes and Watson in the barber shop, then walking arm in arm to through Baker Street. I especially love how the camera pans up from the front door, to the window where Mrs. Hudson opens it just as Holmes and Watson are walking in, and smiles. That camera pan takes my breath away.
But the acting of Nicholas Clay as Dr. Percy Trevelyan was wooden, stiff, and horrible. The man was worse than Hayden Christiansen as Skywalker in the Star Wars Prequel. The second worst actor in the episode, you guessed it, Patrick Newell as Blessington.
Obviously this is forgivable seeing as every single episode (from Adventures, Return, Casebook, Memoirs, and the Films) has amazing actors. I've even though before, the actors they have for bit roles are amazing. But not in this episode. It's sad to see a great story, and a great episode on the whole, have such wooden acting in it.
I almost feel bad saying this seeing as Nicholas Clay died in 2000, but I don't think he would mind. he seems like an actor who would have appreciated the critisim.
But...again, it's forgivable. Seeing Holmes crawl around Blessington's room makes up for it.
Any thoughts?

reply

I thought that the acting was fine.

Actually, I think that the victim here was probably one of the stupidest characters created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The guy knows that a group of criminals want revenge, and yet he remains in England, walks the same route each day, and even hires new staff members when he is most concerned about his life.

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen 🎇

reply

I love the Resident Patient, it's one of my favourites, Clay's performance is fine, I find Newell a little irritating if i'm honest though.

When he said Mr Leeman was dead i thought he said he's still in bed

reply

I was fine with Newell. His character was supposed to be a bit smug, irritating, and too self-confident. I think Blessington really believed that he would never be found. It didn't occur to this doofus that he could have taken off to the States years earlier and he could have hidden himself there. Those other crooks would never have found him. 

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen = 

reply