MovieChat Forums > Tommy (1975) Discussion > Tommy vs. The Wall

Tommy vs. The Wall


OK rock fans. As I write this Tommy is on the Ovation channel, PF The Wall is on Fuse channel. Two iconic fictional rock movies that aren't documentaries or concerts. Which one's better?

As a lifelong Who fan, and only a casual Floyd fan. I would have to go with The Wall against Tommy (and Quadraphenia) unfortunately. While I prefer the albums, the movies don't do it for me.

Let's here you.

reply

I've only seen parts of The Wall but I have to say, compared to the Wall, Quadrophenia is the best album film ever. But did anybody remember Sargent Peppers with Frampton and The Bee Gees?

reply

I love The Beatles, but that movie was horrible.

reply