Bizarre mixture of genres


The Suspicious Death of a Minor (AKA Too Young to Die)

Director Sergio Martino is probably best known these days for his gialli - and this is marketed as such, but it's actually more of a 'police procedural'. An undercover 'loose cannon' cop investigating organised crime in Milan is contacted by an underage prostitute who wishes to pass on information. They meet, but she quickly becomes aware she has been followed and flees to her boarding house. The mysterious figure she was fleeing from tracks her to the boarding house and kills her. The cop makes it his mission to go after the people who were pimping her, in the hopes of closing down their operation and finding the killer. This leads him to a network of underage prostitution, and before long he's up against prominent bankers and businessmen, and connections with kidnapping and drug dealing, as more prostitutes are being killed.

It's a strange film. The subject matter is gritty, and killings by razor and knife are graphically shown. Yet at times it goes full slapstick, including one of the most bizarre car chases I've ever seen, where the occupants of a Citroen 2CV actually pull the doors off their own car and throw them at the pursuing vehicle(!), and (in the course of a ridiculous amount of collateral damage) a bicycle gets hit, resulting in the cyclist riding just the rear wheel like a unicycle, whilst a pedestrian gets knocked over twice, spinning on his head like a breakdancer each time he hits the ground! That said, it's a good story, and the performances (especially those of Claudio Cassinelli as the cop, Lia Tanzi as one of the prostitutes, the always reliable Mel Ferrer as a Police Superintendent, and Roberto Posse as the killer) are excellent. There's also some impressive stunt work, as well as a pretty good Goblin-like score (by Luciano Michelini). 7.5/10

reply

I do not remember the cyclist scene, and I even have the DVD on my shelf. That sounds hilarious and I’ll do a rewatch soon.

reply

Please do!

reply

This was an odd one. I was too tired for part of it and need to re-watch, but it wasn't grabbing me. Other than the opening scene, it didn't seem like a giallo at all, definitely the poliziotteschi variety. Opening with the brutal kill, but then changing to the goofy tone with goofy music made it hard for me to get into. I've generally not taken to the Italian police procedurals but will give some a chance now and then. This story is very urban, and I miss the castles, dress styles and other trappings of the giallo and gothic horror movies.

Maybe it's a mark of how tired I was, but I was confused for the longest time, thinking the killer from the open was the same person as Claudio Cassinelli's character Germi. The shootout on a rollercoaster was cool, don't think I'd seen that before. But the running gags with Germi's glasses or the car door falling off, and then the music which alternated between some funky Starsky & Hutch style music or then the light comedic jaunt just didn't involve me. A lot of the movie seemed designed to get big laughs from a theater audience. Which is odd when the tone of the opening few minutes is anything but funny.

reply

I re-watched this today while fully awake and it all mostly makes sense. Still not near my favorite Sergio Martino by a long shot, but I liked it a little better and can see why some like it. Germi is a pretty cool cop character.

One thing that confused me was the scene where Germi and the two inept cops go to visit an older man for information about one of the dead girls. In the subs for the Italian audio, he talks about "when I lost Marissa's mother..." leading one to think he is Marissa's father or at least related to her. But it would make much more sense if he is the father of Floriana (the girl with the long dark hair who got shot by Menga). And in fact the pictures on the table that Germi looks at both show her, not Marissa. We get more info later that Marissa is the niece of the ultimate baddie, Pesce. The picture that Germi picks up shows three girls - Gloria, Floriana and another girl who's face isn't shown clearly. But she has straight hair, not the curly hair that Marissa is shown with. And there is another picture on the table of just Floriana. So it seems like they are in the home of the father of Floriana. Was it an error in the subtitle? Why was the grieving man talking about Marissa and Marissa's mother?

reply

Funny I just watched this a few days ago - this movie was kinda a "white whale" of eurocrime movies for decades, at least the English version, with it being extremely rare and hard to find. Nowadays the blu-ray is pretty ubiquitous even though it's far from the best example of eurocrime, giallo, or political thrillers of the time.

I think the script was a bit of a mess. It wanted to be a giallo and a crime movie as well as a political message movie about the inherent corruption in the system and underage female hooker trafficking. The issue was that all these ingredients did not blend well together and it gets lost in the whole "buddy cop" dynamic with Cassinelli and the young thief he recruits who is also the comic relief. Then the chase sequences get mega-goofy especially when we have things like a bike turned into a unicycle and a guy spinning on his head not once, but twice! Kinda doesn't fit such serious subject matter, does it?

Cassinelli did a lot better crime / comedy balance with FREE HAND FOR A TOUGH COP the year later. Make sure to get the Fractured Visions UK blu-ray with the commentary because I hear whoever did the commentary on that disc is truly brilliant. One of the best commentators ever, though give him a break as that was his first one. ;)

reply

Your post got me into looking at my DVD and it’s a German release that I’m not able to find much about online. The film does have English subs but its audio commentary does not. Its case and cover art is quite odd. Do you know anything about this release?

Edit: it’s not written on the dvd but I think this is released by a company called Camera Obscura. It’s not stated in the DVD menu either. Very odd.

https://ibb.co/55qS2F5

https://ibb.co/BZzMP2P



reply

The Fractured Visions UK Blu-ray of FREE HAND FOR A TOUGH COP has the brilliant commentary on it by the world's greatest moviechat chatter:

https://blueprintreview.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Free-Hand-for-a-Tough-Cop-3D-Packshot.jpg

THE SUSPICIOUS DEATH OF A MINOR is out in the USA on a Sergio Martino Blu-ray collection in English with its English title on the cover.

https://media.s-bol.com/R8Zypo113EQE/AnBWZ99/550x790.jpg
(same art but that's the UK release of the same disc)

reply

I do have that exact release of Free Hand for a Tough Cop and I’ll be checking out the commentary. 👍

Great so far. You are so right about the amount of character actors in this one, and that really is one of my favorite things about Italian genre cinema in general. I would have never known about the actor from Fulci’s Zombie being the guy who gets shot in the bank. :)

reply

I have a question for you. During your commentary, you mention we are about to be introduced to an actress who is the first macguffin of the film. This is said during a scene where Cassinelli and Milian are holding a guy at gunpoint. I swear that actor is Daniel Ades, who was in Aguirre the Wrath of God, but I can’t find him listed under the cast. I might have missed you mentioning his name earlier. Is that him?

https://ibb.co/fr67SYy

reply

Ah you're referring to the character of "Rabat" who is uncredited. He does look a lot like him, though in my opinion he also looks a lot like Christoph Waltz.

https://www.thrillingforum.com/phpbb/download/file.php?id=276418

It's a possibility, though he didn't really do any Italian movies at the time (mainly the international stuff he did was in South America). It would be interesting to know for sure. I know Italian movies had a law against crediting more than 2 International actors per movie (though there were many exceptions) so American Ex-pat non-star guys like John P. Dulaney went uncredited most of the time. I wonder how he would have been connected to the film? Perhaps he buddied up with Peter Berling on set who got him a guest role in an Italian film for a free vacation?

Note that the character is not listed here either, and this site has a wealth of identifications for Italian crime movie casts:
https://www.pollanetsquad.it/scheda.php?sez=film&cod=49&stream=ZyVtFVxv7rM

reply

Wow. He looks so similar to Christoph Waltz. I wish there were a way to find out who that actor is.

reply

It must be him or Waltz. :)

https://image.pmgstatic.com/cache/resized/w663/files/images/film/photos/160/488/160488485_3850cd.jpg

reply

Ah you know what, I had forgotten about THE LAST MOVIE, which was made before AGUIRRE, so you are starting to look very possibly correct. Both Tomas Milian and Daniel Ades were of Cuban origin and both worked on LAST MOVIE... so there's a strong chance it was Milian who got him a role on FREE HAND. There's nothing going against this because that actor, whoever he was, was not credited and isn't on any website. It could have just fallen through the cracks because he wasn't famous enough for anyone to spot him.

reply

I went ahead and added it to imdb. Thank you for solving an age-old mystery. :D

reply