MovieChat Forums > Star Trek (1966) Discussion > Are DVDs Without CGI Sold Anymore?

Are DVDs Without CGI Sold Anymore?


I see "remastered" which sounds like CGI added. I'm looking for the original TV versions.

reply

I don't know whether they're still selling the "plain" version or not. But "remastered" means merely that they went back to the 50-year-old original films and physically cleaned them up a bit to restore the original clarity and brightness. They also added some CGI -- but there's an option to turn that OFF and show just the cleaned-up original. Both versions look very nice!

We watched everything through once with the CGI turned ON, and most of it was just a more realistic-looking version of the original. But then (in my opinion) they got carried away and added some stuff, including at least one brief scene -- there's a long shot of T'Pring's wedding party approaching Kunat Kalifi, crossing a natural bridge over a chasm. From watching the original, I never had the impression that there were any chasms around, and I don't recall any other such depictions of Vulcan (e.g., in the Animated Series or the original-cast movies). Now admittedly there might be just about anything somewhere on Vulcan, but I would have strongly preferred that -- if they were going to show the approach of the wedding party at all -- they would have shown them crossing a relatively flat desert landscape such as I remember from "Yesteryear" and "The Motion Picture" (and please correct me if either of those showed non-flat landscapes). But that's just me -- others may prefer the more-rugged landscape.

reply

"there's a long shot of T'Pring's wedding party approaching Kunat Kalifi, crossing a natural bridge over a chasm"

The other day, I rewatched Search for Spock, and there was a great shot of a tiny bridge over a vast chasm near the end on Vulcan, so it's part of the natural landscape OF Vulcan.

reply

Thanks -- I need to rewatch Search for Spock -- knowing about that scene does make me feel better. But I still think that adding a scene (even a brief one) to TOS falls outside the purview of "remastering" and/or "enhancing."

reply

"option to turn that OFF and show just the cleaned-up original."

Thanks! That's a relief! I don't mind a cleaned-up original, but I don't like the added CGI scenes. Ditto with the Lucas Specialized Star Wars version.

reply

I probably shouldn't be saying this, but looking things NOT from corporate and financial interests of the wealthy and powerful, but from the perspective of 'what's best for the people', I can reveal that it's pretty easy to find those versions.. I don't know, in a non-physical form that might exist in the faraway future of 'after 2000', where things might be.. 'online'.. as in 'files' and such?

I mean, they might be ARCHIVED somewhere, possibly... (nudge)

What? Why would I nudge twice?

reply

The "original" TV versions are DEAD.

Which is a good thing, too: in comparison with The Next Generation and onwards, the TOS original effects would stick out like a sore thumb. Best to improve the effects and MOVE ON.

reply

I'm all in favor of offering -- as an option -- improved special effects (more realistic-looking ships, a less "plywood" look to the sets, etc.). But I'm also in favor of preserving A) the time-degraded look of the originals, and B) the remastered originals WITHOUT the improved effects. It's history, and some people are interested in being able to see it that way -- as another option.

reply

If you want the option, I'm sure the media is available second-hand on Ebay. I mean, I had those discs myself, once.

reply

Look around secondhand shops, you may still find all seasons for a cheap price.

reply

Why the hell would anyone buy DVDs? I've seen Blu Ray players in thrift shops.
Remastered means redoing HD scans of the 35mm film. Color correction and touch ups. In 2006!
All the space scenes are redone with CG. Do you realize the old ones look like shit?

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0060028/alternateversions?tab=cz

In 2006, CBS went back to the archives and created HD prints of every episode of the show. In addition to the new video transfer, they re-did all of the model shots and some matte paintings using CGI effects, and re-recorded the original theme song to clean it up. These "Enhanced" versions of the episodes aired on syndication and have been released on DVD and Blu-Ray.

reply

The CGI looks like shit.

The originals are classic. CGI is not the original.
Neither do I want to see "I Love Lucy" in color.

I have a Blue Ray player and a few DVD players. DVDs are fine.

reply


Why the hell would anyone buy DVDs?


One reason would be to own the physical media. Once you own them, they can't cancel you out unless the federales intends to break down your door to confiscate them.

This presupposes that the DVD owner will still have or have access to an operable machine in the future.

reply

The blu ray set for each season that I have has optional with or without special effects in them.

reply

THANKS!

reply